Subscribe to industry newsletters

Search jobs

Down in the dumps

For generations mining has been the goose that laid the golden egg (literally) for the South African economy. But most mines do have a finite life, and their closing has an impact not only on the environment but also on the surrounding community. So whose responsibility is it to put everything together again and how should it be done?
Down in the dumps
© rustyphil – 123RF.com
The Centre for Environmental Rights held a seminar entitled "Mine Closure and Rehabilitation: From Dereliction to Accountability?" in Cape Town recently.

A global perspective


Of course, accountability and rehabilitation of former mining areas is not only a South African dilemma, but a challenge that takes place worldwide.
According to Professor Caroline Digby, Adjunct Professor and Director for the Centre of Sustainability in Mining and Industry, the aim of responsible mining should be to:
  • Achieve zero harm
  • Realise net positive environmental impact
  • Improve social performance
  • Leave a positive legacy

What's going wrong?


"Firstly there is a deep resistance to talking about closure and a perception that mines never close," she points out.

Then there's the chain of custody - those that open mines, develop closure plans, build relationships with communities and make financial provision, are seldom still around to close the mine.

"Governance after closure and timeframes for building social, human capital and sustainable businesses takes time - often longer than the life of the mine. The current focus is also on individual mine and local scale, rather than having a multi-mine and regional approach," Prof. Digby says.

Other approaches


She borrows from a submission made by the Chamber of Mines to the Human Rights Commission to explain how things should change: "No mine can close independently of its neighbours - there is a need to rethink the kind of tools that we use to manage impacts. If a mine closes prematurely, that mine has impacts on its neighbours; mines cannot have a stand-alone closure plan."

The South African scenario


Professor Tracey-Ann Humby, Associate Professor: School of Law, University of the Witwatersrand, says that the scope of the problem in South Africa stretches to 6000 derelict or ownerless mines, the significance of the rehabilitation and the pace at which it takes place.

Then there is the human tragedy aspect. For example, the zamma zamma or illegal miners who are killed in territorial disputes and while working in dangerous circumstances, as well as the irreversible impact on the environment, and the health and social fabric of surrounding communities.

Making things right


Prof. Humby outlines a number of points that need to be taken into consideration when planning mine closures:
  • It should be tackled at all phases of the mining lifecycle
  • Legacy issues, which include financial resources, cooperative governance and the legal framework
  • Provide a sustainable economic assessment for mining development and regional closure in South Africa
  • Ensure new environmental regulations on auditing are properly resourced
  • Finalise the draft financial provision regulations with joint civil society/government/business oversight of trust funds
  • Ensure assessments include other critical social issues, such as paying for electricity for mine/mining villages
  • Research into an appropriate legal framework for artisanal and small-scale mining operations
  • Clarify the role of the liquidators
  • Formulate a special procedure for winding up resource-based companies
  • Mandatory transparency

Mine closures and rehabilitation is a complex challenge and something the country is going to face for decades to come. Therefore, the solution appears to incorporate a multi-disciplinary approach comprising private and public participation, financial and environmental regulations and complete transparency.

About Nicci Botha

Nicci Botha has been wordsmithing for more than 20 years, covering just about every subject under the sun and then some. She's strung together words on sustainable development, maritime matters, mining, marketing, medical, lifestyle... and that elixir of life - chocolate. Nicci has worked for local and international media houses including Primedia, Caxton, Lloyd's and Reuters. Her new passion is digital media.



Let's do Biz