Most Read

  • Introducing TFGLabs: Investment in omnichannel technology continues to transform TFG
    Leading fashion and lifestyle retailer TFG shared its strategy to revolutionise the omnichannel experience and transform into Africa's leading high-tech omnichannel retailer. "We are laying the foundations to become the largest, most reliable and most profitable e-commerce destination on the continent; via a simplified, customer-centric approach, aimed at maximising group scale, minimising duplication and cost, and leveraging our incredible assets," shared newly appointed co-chief omni officer Claude Hanan. The announcement came as part of the retailer's 2021 financial year-end presentation. Issued by TFG (The Foschini Group)
  • All the winners from the 2021 Luxe Restaurant Awards
    Last night, 8 June, The Hospitality Counsel hosted their 3rd annual Luxe Restaurant Awards, celebrating the finest contributions to the South African restaurant industry, at AURUM restaurant within The Leonardo, Africa's tallest skyscraper.
  • Ster-Kinekor, SA State Theatre announce lineup of theatre productions
    Ster-Kinekor Theatres (SKT) and the South African State Theatre have announced the lineup of theatre productions that will be screened at cinemas across the country from 18 June 2021.
Show more
Business services


More...Submit news
Advertise on Bizcommunity

Subscribe to industry newsletters

Medical aid and freedom of choice

The recent threat by Julius Malema's Economic Freedom Fighters to withdraw from Parliament's medical aid scheme has placed the spotlight firmly on companies insisting that employees make use their preferred service provider(s).
By virtue of the EFF action, the question of an employee's "freedom of choice" when it comes to selecting their medical scheme is very much in the public domain.

While in terms of South African law, a company can enforce membership of a particular scheme if it is written into an employee's contract or that firm pays a subsidy, many people feel the choice should be their own.

The EFF claims the current scheme was imposed on MPs through "illegal apartheid legislation", and that parliamentarians were "wilfully compliant" with it.

In terms of the scheme each MP pays R4,300 a month, an account which party spokesman Mbuyisini Ndlozi says excludes dependents, meaning MPs pay no less than R8,300 a month.


Yet it is not only parliamentarians who find themselves in the position of being forcibly subscribed to a certain medical aid.

Internet forums are littered with complaints from people arguing that they should be allowed to choose their own schemes, very often because they feel that more affordable options will be of more value to their spouses and families.

At the root of the issue is the fact that many employees seek to restrict the medical schemes available to their employees to limit payroll administration.

However, the situation is exacerbated by the fact that most companies today offer Total Cost to Company packages as there is no longer any tax benefit or incentive for them to subsidise all or part of their companies' medical aid.

'Serious discussion is needed'

"For these employees it is therefore apparent that there are absolutely NO grounds as to why they should be limited to certain schemes," says Genesis Medical scheme executive Brian Watson.

These sentiments are shared by chair of the National Consumer Forum, Thami Bolani, who believes the issue is one that needs "serious discussion".

"One thing about the EFF's protest about the government medical aid is that it has highlighted this issue for consumers," he says.

"Usually companies make use of larger medical schemes, and that eliminates the competition from smaller schemes that may actually offer better value. It is very often the case that a smaller scheme will deliver a much more personal service."

Bolani says at the end of the day, employees should not be forced into a particular medical aid simply because it makes payroll administration easier.

"People should have freedom of choice," Bolani says.

For more information click here.

About John Harvey

John Harvey is Media Relations Consultant at Roger Wilco, an established, award-winning digital marketing agency based in Cape Town. He was weaned and came of age on a very unhealthy diet of newsprint and post-midnight deadlines - yet still comes back for more.
    -- Anon --
    yes - it also means that schemes can offer bad service and there is little you as the member can do... join or else.
    Posted on 25 Jun 2014 11:18



    Let's do Biz