The Loerie Awards 2005 News South Africa

Loerie judging incorporated new rules this year

This year The Loerie Awards had two international judges and a number of changes to the judging and entry process this year to ensure impartiality. All entries were labelled anonymously - no agency names visible - and there was a ballot system for voting, instead of the traditional show of hands.

International judge, Prasoon Joshi, McCann-Erickson India's Regional Creative Director for South Asia & South East Asia, cancelled at the last minute. Steve Henry of HHCL/red cell, stepped in instead as alternate jury chair of the Advertising Category judging panel. The Jury Chairman for the Design category was Ken Cato, an Australian designer with an international reputation, and Chairman of Cato Purnell Partners. Cato's participation was made possible by the Design Indaba - a partner of The Loerie Awards in the newly formed Creative Alliance.

Across all categories, Loerie Awards 2005 judges were looking for one thing - creative excellence; work that is exceptional in execution, and relevant to its target audience, said The Loerie Awards committee.

"The task to seek out work that is bold and innovative and that challenges convention will be formidable, but I'm more than comfortable that the judging panels have the experience and the skills to identify it," said Chair, Wing Wing Mdlulwa at the time.

Winning campaigns will be showing at the local Margate cinema throughout The Loerie Awards weekend, 15 and 16 October 2005. The Loerie Awards will be having its first Travelling Exhibition, which will showcase the best work the industry has to offer by visiting major centres as well as schools and colleges throughout the country. This will promote the industry and inspire young, up-and-coming creatives to create their own award-winning work.

The full list of judges on the advertising category panel was:

Steve HenryExecutive Creative Director-HHCL/red cell (Alternate Jury Chair)
Wingwing MdlulwaExecutive Creative DirectorAfricaExtraBold
Ivan JohnsonCreative DirectorBerry Bush BBDO CT
Brett MorrisExecutive Creative DirectorFCB JHB
Kamal GangaramCreative DirectorFCB JHB
Sandile MkhasibeCreative DirectorHerdbuoys McCann
Pepe MaraisExecutive Creative DirectorJoe Public
Alistair KingExecutive Creative DirectorKingJames CT
Rob McLennanCreative DirectorLowe Bull JHB
Roger PaulseCreative DirectorLowe Bull CT
Vanessa PearsonExecutive Creative Director Lobedu Leo Burnett
Mike SchalitChief Creative OfficerNet#Work BBDO
Asheen NaiduCopy Writer Net#Work BBDO
Gerry HumanExecutive Creative DirectorOgilvy JHB
Mark FisherExecutive Creative DirectorOgilvy CT
Rajesh RanchodExecutive Creative DirectorSaatchi & Saatchi
Graham WarsopExecutive Creative DirectorTJDR JHB
Ahmed TillyCreative DirectorTJDR CT
Sandy de WittExecutive Creative DirectorTBWA HuntLascaris
Festus MasekwamengCopy WriterTBWA Hunt Lascaris
Tshebo MokoenaMarketing ManagerSAFM
John CulverwellCEO Sonovision
Dave HarrisSound EngineerFrequency
Tony BaggotDirector Freize Films
Alun RichardsSound EngineerCut ñ Paste
Marcel MoutonEditor Visual Assault

The Design Category judging panel comprised:

CHAIR: Ken CatoChairmanCato Purnell Partners
Gaby De Abreu Switch Design Group
Gary Harwood Co Founder Harwood Kirsten Leigh McCoy
George Rautenbach Creative DirectorTequila
Jenny Ehlers Creative Director King James RSVP
Jeremy Sampson Founder/CEOInterbrand Sampson
Joanne Thomas Jupiter Drawing Room CT
Joey Pastoll Cross Colours
Nathan Reddy GRID
Sean Harrison CEO Code [a Company of Designers]
Sharon Lister Enterprise IG
Ithateng Mokgoro Design DirectorGamatong Design Enterprise
Veejay Archary Black, Brand, Strategy & Design
Mary Pillay Design Director House Of Shakti
Carlo Murison Two Tone Branding
Faith Mokale Shot Left
Bright Hlatswayo Ogilvy
Richard Hart Design Director disturbance

The Direct Category judging panel comprised:

CHAIR: Nici StathacopoulosCEO The Tipping Point
Lisa Christopher Creative Director Lesoba Difference
Andrew Ambrigione Creative Director Action Ambrose
Ian Oliver CEO Oliver McIntyre
Luke Hartdegen CD/Freelance DWF
Annemie Franke lecturer University of Pretoria.
Jolande Duvenage Head: Member ExperienceeBucks
Maseda Ratshikuni Senior Marketing ManagerNedbank
Lucien Van Huyssteen Brand Marketing ManagerBrandhouse
Sarita Mans Marketing Director Tsogo Sun
Glynn Venter Creative Director FCB CT 361
Matshepo Molapo Senior Manager Direct Mail Centre JHB
Michelle Pithey Art Director Network BBDO
Petra Oelofse Creative Director Tequila
Karin Barry Creative Group Head Ogilvy Johannesburg

The Corporate Video category judges are:

Peter CarrProducerVelocity Films (CHAIR)
Fran Luckin Ogilvy
Gersh KgamediDirectorPicture Tree
Kevin van der Molen Gearhouse
Mahle Kwababa Ogilvy
Michelle Caldeira Blue Moon
Mickey DubeFilm DirectorCPA
Moonyeen Lee Theatre MLA
Nina Morris Morris Jones
Peter Bond O'Mage
Phindile Mkhabele Dreamcatcher
Spero Patricios Launch Factory
Vuyani Plata Herdbuoys McCann
Warren Stewart VWV
Zwelakhe Tshabangu Lowe Bull

Interactive category:

The first round of some Interactive categories will be judged by a remote panel of judges. Thereafter, finalists will be judged at the judging venue.

Final and Remote panel:

Kirstin Brown International Healthcare Distributors
Matthew BucklandPublisherMail & Guardian Online
Christo DohertyProfessor/Head of Digital ArtsWits School of Arts (WSOA)
Arthur GoldstuckManaging DirectorWorld Wide Worx
Uwe Gütschow AtPlay
Alison JacobsonManaging DirectorReusable Objects
Graunt Krugerunder-grad in Politics and Journalism at Rhodes with academic colours
Jonathan McKayCreative DirectorEject Media
Gustav PraekeltFounding PartnerPraekelt Consulting
Andre RademanManaging DirectorBizcommunity.com
Gavin RookeManaging DirectorTrigger
Johan SaaimanCreative PartnerVINYL
Tebogo SerobatseDirectorOrange Factory
Brent ShahimManaging DirectorAqua Online
Grant ShippeyChief Executive OfficerAmorphous
Mark WilliamsCEOAshland Communications JHB
Alison WrightManaging DirectorStriata SA (Pty) Ltd

Remote Only Panel:

Justin BradburyCreative/Technical DirectorCreative technologist
Diane LarsenCreative DirectorPhynxe
Jason LevinConsultantTBWA
Hilton TennantPartner/Creative DirectorTennant McKay
Michele SandersCreative DirectorSix Million Dollar Media
Nathaniel SternArtist/lecturerWits' Digital Arts MA programme
Preston ThomasTechnical DirectorPixel Project
Paul ToozeCreative DirectorWireframe Studio
Templar WalesExecutive Creative Directorblink new media
Adam WhitehouseCreative DirectorSTONEWALL+
Mark WinklerExecutive Creative DirectorRipe Design South Africa

The Integrated Campaign Category was judged by a selection of judges made up from the other panels.

Major sponsors on board for this year's event are M-Net, Media24, The Direct Mail Centre and The South African Breweries Limited (major sponsors). Other sponsors are Tourism Kwa-Zulu Natal, Kulula.com, brandhouse, YFM, Cell C, Beith Digital, OpenAd, Sappi, Hetzner Internet Hosting, Paygate Internet payment gateway, Ugu District Municipality, King James RSVP, and Six Million Dollar.

The Loerie Awards committee comprises Wingwing Mdlulwa, Chairman (Creative Circle), Andrew Human, Managing Director, Russell Cory (Financial Officer), Dee Blackie (MFSA), Veejay Archary (Think), Peter Carr (Commercial Producers Association), Nonjabulo Hlengwa (Café), Gerry Human (Creative Circle), Maserame Mouyeme (Association for Communication and Advertising), Mike Schalit (Creative Circle), Nici Stathacopoulos (Direct), and Roelof van Wyk (Interactive).

Let's do Biz