Most Read

  • AI and retail: A South African conundrum
    AI and retail: A South African conundrum
    Artificial intelligence (AI) is being successfully deployed in the global retail sector, but it needs to be used carefully in the South African context, taking into account specific market characteristics. By Wendy Tembedza
  • Paula Hulley
    Paula Hulley, IAB SA CEO, steps down
    Haydn Townsend, IAB SA chair has announced that Paula Hulley, IAB SA CEO will not be renewing her contract into 2022.
  • Let’s Talk Digital is hosted by Audrey Naidoo
    Let's Talk Digital podcast launches on Bizcommunity
    This September, Let's Talk Digital, a new multimedia offering launches on Bizcommunity. The bi-weekly podcast, hosted by Audrey Naidoo and produced by Tyran De Beer, features conversations with leading voices in the SA digital marketing and media space.
  • Helen R. McIntee, president of the African Marketing Confederation
    The AMC announces relaunch
    The African Marketing Confederation (AMC) has announced its relaunch, with updated vision and goals. The AMC is a pan-African body of marketing professionals with the aim to bring national marketing bodies and associations of nine countries together.
  • Red & Yellow partners with Unilever on BCom in Marketing degree
    Red & Yellow partners with Unilever on BCom in Marketing degree
    A partnership between the Red & Yellow Creative School of Business and global FMCG giant Unilever looks to produce future-fit graduates ready for the challenging and rewarding world of marketing.
  • South Africa's proposed Startup Act to be revealed soon
    South Africa's proposed Startup Act to be revealed soon
    On 16 September, startup ecosystem stakeholders will be revealing the latest findings and plans towards the development of a proposed South African Startup Act - a call to the president to unleash the growth and innovation inherent in the country's entrepreneurs and youth. These findings, gathered over the past six months via desktop research, focus groups and research contributed by the World Bank, provide a holistic overview of the problems affecting the ability of startups to establish, grow and scale in South Africa.
  • Source: ©Andriy Popov
    The need to curb money laundering
    The Anti-Money Laundering (AML) market makes up a significant proportion of the global Gross Domestic Product (GDP), but the real issue is that money laundering is used to fund other illicit activities, such as smuggling, bribery, corruption, cybercrime, illegal arms dealing, human trafficking, modern slavery, and more. By Amit Singh
  • Henriëtte Loubser, Netwerk24's editor-in-chief
    Netwerk24 undergoing a metamorphosis
    Netwerk24, the acting digital home of Media24's Afrikaans titles, is moving to a new platform in early October. It will also be launching a brand new app.
  • EXCLUSIVE: Craig Naicker talks Happy Friday
    EXCLUSIVE: Craig Naicker talks Happy Friday
    CWDi has been rebirthed as Happy Friday by reinventing the agency model - for staff and clients alike. By Evan-Lee Courie
  • Net#work BBDO has a 'meltdown'
    Net#work BBDO has a 'meltdown'
    Everything has changed. That is a given. And so when Net#work BBDO moved into their new offices and started unpacking the 27 years of awards haul for the shelves, the leadership team had, well, a meltdown.
Show more
Advertise on Bizcommunity

Subscribe to industry newsletters

ELA goes to court over Thabametsi's environmental impact

Coal-fired power stations are South Africa's single largest source of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and Earthlife Africa (ELA) argues that the environmental impact assessment (EIA) to construct Thabametsi did not adequately assess the climate change impacts of the facility, and that these impacts should have been assessed before a decision was made on whether to go ahead with the power station.
ELA goes to court over Thabametsi's environmental impactThe impact assessment was made available for public comment in January 2017 following the minister of environmental affairs’ decision to order Thabametsi to conduct an assessment of the climate change impacts of the proposed coal-fired power station in water-stressed Limpopo.

At the same time, the minister decided to uphold the proposed power station’s environmental authorisation – a decision which ELA will be challenging in court from Thursday.

The case

ELA, represented by the Centre for Environmental Rights (CER), yesterday submitted comments on the draft climate change impact assessment for the Thabametsi power station.
ELA’s case is based on the fact that climate change impacts are significant environmental impacts, given the impacts that climate change will have and is having on water availability and temperature increases for example, particularly in respect of a proposed coal-fired power station.

Thabametsi and the state however, argue that Thabametsi’s EIA did consider climate change; that there is, in any event, no legal obligation to assess climate change impacts; and that the department of environmental affairs (DEA) can subsequently amend the conditions of the authorisation, and the authorisation can be revoked if those conditions are not being met.

The climate change impact assessment released for public comment by independent consultants appointed by Thabametsi states that:
  • The magnitude of the power station’s emissions (8,2m tons of CO2 equivalent per year) is very large based on a GHG magnitude scale drawing from various international lender organisation standards;
  • The plant does not represent an improvement on the emissions intensity of South Africa’s grid, but only represents an improvement (from a GHG emissions perspective) on South Africa’s three oldest coal-fired power plants – Camden, Hendrina and Arnot;
  • the impacts of climate change particularly on water availability, water quality and temperature increases are likely to pose a high risk to the power station in the short to long-term future; and
  • drought conditions have historically negatively impacted local communities, including farmers and other rural residents directly dependent on water supplies for cattle farming and other agriculture in the Lephalale. Increased water stress may bring about increased community concerns and tension, and the increased dry spells/drought events will affect communities and may threaten Thabamesti’s “social licence to operate”.

Cannot be mitigated or remedied

CER attorney Nicole Löser says: “This assessment shows that Thabametsi’s environmental impact report failed at assessing the climate change impacts of the power station and was incorrect in concluding that the GHG emissions of the power station would not be significant. It also shows that the climate change-related risks cannot be mitigated or remedied. In this case, the most cautious and risk-averse recommendation, as required by law, would be that the power station should not proceed.”

While ELA has commended Thabametsi for the thorough assessment of the climate change impacts, they have also pointed out that it fails to give adequate consideration to the impacts that the power station will have for communities and the environment, and how these impacts will be exacerbated by the impacts of climate change. The assessment also fails to make adequate or effective recommendations in light of the significant risks that it brings to light.

Water-stressed area

Makoma Lekalakala of ELA says: “With the Waterberg being a water stressed area, we have always had concerns over the mass influx of proposed water-intensive developments, such as power stations, in the area, particularly the impacts that this will have for communities and farmers who depend on the limited water available. This report confirms our long held concerns that water availability is likely to pose a high risk for the Thabametsi power station and communities in the area.”

Thabametsi must submit its final climate change impact assessment in March 2017. In the meantime, the question on whether the minister could have upheld the environmental authorisation without the climate change impacts having been assessed, will be argued in SA’s first climate change lawsuit on Thursday, 2 and Friday, 3 March in the Pretoria High Court.
To celebrate Biz's 20th birthday month, get 20% off all rate card products:

Let's do Biz