News

Industries

Companies

Jobs

Events

People

Video

Audio

Galleries

Submit content

My Account

Advertise with us

Almost half of AI martech projects fail as SA companies don't complete what they started

Two-fifths, or 1,143 or 40.1%, of South African organisations’ 2,848 pieces of marketing technology are not in use or are not delivering value, not because of budget, ambition or technology but because companies fail to complete projects they start.
South African organisations own 2,848 pieces of<p>marketing technology between them and describe 1,143 of those, or 40.1%, as either not in use or not delivering value because they finish far less than they start (Image source: © 123rf )
South African organisations own 2,848 pieces of

marketing technology between them and describe 1,143 of those, or 40.1%, as either not in use or not delivering value because they finish far less than they start (Image source: © 123rf 123rf)

“What we are short of is completion. We buy, we pilot, we explore, and we intend, and we finish far less than we start," explains Digitlab CEO Mike Saunder, publisher of Insight 2027.

The judgement on what is working comes from the organisations themselves rather than from external audit. What fails follows a consistent pattern.

  • Technology with a narrow, self-contained job is implemented reliably: cookie and consent management is described as idle or ineffective by 30.3% of the organisations that own it, and content management systems by 34.7%.

  • Technology that depends on connected data or an agreed process fails far more often, including influencer and affiliate management at 50.0% of owners, omnichannel messaging at 49.6%, customer data platforms at 48.6% and loyalty systems at 48.5%.

The same pattern in measurement

The study records the same pattern in measurement. Return on investment is tracked by 59.8% of organisations, while 25.0% can attribute revenue to digital activity and 13.4% track a customer’s progression through their own customer relationship system. More than a quarter, 27.7%, track none of the six revenue-linked measures the study asked about.

Artificial Intelligence

“Eighty-six per cent of the organisations we surveyed held or grew their marketing budget last year, and almost everybody is trying artificial
intelligence (AI)," says Saunders.

On AI, the number of functions an organisation is exploring bears no statistical relationship to the state of its data foundations, while the number running in production is closely related to it. Organisations with the strongest foundations run 4.7 of nine functions in production and those with the weakest run 1.3, while 29.2% have none in production at all.

The same divide appears in budgets: marketing budgets grew for 61.6% of organisations whose customer relationship system is working, 45.0% of those with no system and 42.3% of those owning one that is not running; the group also most likely to have cut its budget at 19.7%.

The working-system effect holds after controlling for company size and digital budget intensity, and size itself has no measurable effect.

Size is irrelevant

Size explains little elsewhere in the study.

Of the 93 segment associations that survive correction for multiple comparisons, company size accounts for three, an organisation’s data strategy stage for 31 and the digital share of its marketing budget for 30.

“The organisations growing in this research are not the ones with the most technology or the biggest budgets,” says Saunders.

“They are the ones that finished something. They connected the customer record to the report that reads it, they can see revenue arriving, and they put two or three AI functions into production instead of exploring nine. "

He adds that this is also why they are asking the industry to stop benchmarking against companies of a similar size and start benchmarking against organisations at a similar level of data maturity.

“Size tells you very little about capability in South Africa. What a business has finished tells you a great deal.”

About the report

The report was the opening keynote of the recent Digital Marketing Conference in Cape Town.

The research covers 336 organisations, 94.6% of them South African, each answering 161 questions on budget, technology, measurement, artificial intelligence, channels and skills.It is the second annual wave of the study, following 329 respondents in 2025.

Digitlab and The Lekker Network will also present the full findings in an online webinar on 18 November 2026 at 4 pm. Registration is open here.

Let's do Biz