News

Industries

Companies

Jobs

Events

People

Video

Audio

Galleries

Submit content

My Account

Advertise with us

Search jobs
Advertise your job vacancies

    Subscribe & Follow


    Lift-and-shift strategy is arrogance dressed up as efficiency

    Too many global brands arrive in Africa with strategies that worked somewhere else. Many leave again, quietly, with write-downs and talk of a "challenging operating environment".
    Lift-and-shift strategy is arrogance dressed up as efficiency

    The usual explanation is the continent itself: infrastructure, currencies, regulation. Our research for Africa's Beautiful Constraints found a less comfortable answer. Most of these strategies were never designed for Africa. They were inherited from other markets, and the people implementing them were given little leeway or budget to localise them effectively.

    In Challenger Strategy, we call locked-in behaviour like this path dependence. It is one of the most expensive blind spots in any emerging-market play.

    Best practice, made somewhere else

    In a presentation deck, path dependence usually shows up as a slide titled "best practice". Best practice becomes a problem when nobody asks how it directly addresses a local insight and local need.

    In many go-to-market models, price pack architecture, channel strategy, service design, media approach, research methodology and operating models are set in a home market, for that market's conditions. Then they're shipped into Africa unexamined, in the name of efficiency. They become expensive impositions rather than assets.

    Imported answers to local questions

    When we interviewed business leaders and CMOs across the continent for Africa's Beautiful Constraints, almost all of them named arrogance as one of the biggest obstacles newcomers face. Lift and shift is arrogance dressed up as efficiency.

    In Mozambique, Filipa Neves, then marketing director at The Heineken Company, told us that most shoppers say mango is their favourite juice, yet tutti frutti outsells it by far. People buy the blend that keeps the whole household happy – "you would never see that in Europe".

    Ask a blunt research question and many respondents will tell you what they think you want to hear. And where "buy in bulk and save" is common elsewhere, in much of Africa people need, or can only afford, micro-portions – what Kenyans call the kadogo economy.

    Indomie shows us the way: when the Tolaram Group brought instant noodles to Nigeria in 1988, almost nobody ate them, and early sales were poor. Rather than retreat, Tolaram learned that Nigerians valued noodles for saving scarce cooking time and fuel, not as a snack. It partnered with a local manufacturer, set up its own logistics company and built gas power plants for its factories. It also designed tougher packs for sales in open markets, created Jollof Chicken flavour and launched sizes from a 70g kids' pack to a 210g Belle-full. Indomie now holds around 70% of a US$1 billion category it created in Nigeria.

    You can't change a system from the outside

    Many multinationals arrive wanting to modernise a channel or formalise a category. The ambition is often a good one, but they're trying to do it from the outside.

    Systems change from the inside. As Thebe Ikalafeng, founder and chairman at Brand Africa, put it, "Coca-Cola is so successful in Africa because they are local, wherever they are." It runs on local bottlers. Where Moroccan roads are too narrow for trucks, it moves by donkey cart and camel. Nobody at head office could have designed that.

    On what Filipa Neves calls Africa's bumpy road, the route to market is the strategy. Parmalat took wrapped cheese slices, seen as out of reach for low-income consumers, into spaza shops and township kota vendors. It built its own database of informal outlets and created a market that GG Alcock, in his book Kasinomics, estimated at about R1bn.

    South Africa, this means you too

    South African companies have paid for some of the most expensive lessons. Retailers, food producers and grocers have all gone into Nigeria and Ghana and come home again. Currency and regulation played their part, but many arrived assuming that what worked in Johannesburg would work in Lagos.

    Being African is not the same as being local. Thebe Ikalafeng's antidote: "My secret is I leave South Africa at the airport." Meet people, eat the food, and arrive with "an open mind, an open heart, an open stomach, and open hands." Or as Avukile Mabombo, head of customer marketing at Bacardi, put it: "You've got to be open to the idea that you're going to have to do things differently here."

    Where to start

    Breaking path dependence takes humility and patience, and it starts with an honest audit. Go through your strategy and go-to-market approach, including pack formats, sizes, prices, channels and research methods, and question everything against local conditions. If you can't explain why each choice fits this market, it probably doesn't.

    As Firoze Bhorat, chief marketing officer at Discovery Limited, told us, Africa has less inherited structure to lock you in and, in many respects, it's a blank canvas. We should not impose an imported set of ideas onto that canvas just because they worked elsewhere.

    You should also ask who wins locally if you win locally. If the answer is no-one, find the partners, suppliers and talent whose success depends on yours. Otherwise, you will quickly be labelled extractive. Finally, check where the board members' heads are at. Success in Africa is measured in years, and if the board wants returns in 18 months, you need to fix that expectation before you start.

    Strategies that worked elsewhere earned their place there. In Africa, they must earn it again.

    About David Blyth

    David Blyth is the founder and CEO of Delta Victor Bravo (representing eatbigfish in Africa).
    eatbigfish
    We're obsessed with challenger brands. They shake things up. They change the rules. They get famous. And they do it with passion and smarts, not big budgets or easy answers.
    More news
    Let's do Biz