Picture a creator post that clocks 83,000 likes, 4,600 comments and 11,000 shares. Somebody forwards the dashboard with a "great work, team" and the budget conversation for next quarter pretty much writes itself.
But here's the question worth asking before you put more rands behind it: was it good for the brand? Could people tell who it was for, and did it give them a reason to consider you?
South African marketers are asking this at exactly the right time. A net 61% of marketers planned to increase spend on influencers and creators in 2026, and 91% already use them, according to Kantar's Media Reactions research. The money is moving fast. The measurement hasn't kept up.
The engagement trap
Kantar analysed more than 15,000 pieces of sponsored creator content across TikTok, Instagram and YouTube. It compared platform engagement (likes and comments per view) with predicted brand-building and sales potential. The two lined up in only about one in three cases.
Look only at the highly engaging posts and it gets starker. Fewer than one in five show strong potential to build the brand, and roughly one in eight to drive short-term sales. For every ten posts that look brilliant on the dashboard, around eight are unlikely to move your business in any meaningful way.
Platform engagement metrics tell you what the algorithm rewards, but are on their own poor predictors of whether that investment will deliver for your business. By all means, keep an eye on the likes. Just don't let them be the only thing you count.
Start with the job, not the name
Most creator briefs begin with a person: someone we like, someone trending, someone with a big following. Kantar's alternative is to ask what we need the creator to do that the brand can't do alone. There are three answers.
The messenger gives you access to an audience. L'Oréal runs an always-on creator club across its portfolio, with clear governance on fit, disclosure and responsible content, while creators still speak in their own voices.
The co-author brings the creativity. CeraVe gave comedian Anwar Jibawi one product truth, that its foaming cleanser suits combination skin. He turned it into a TikTok retelling of Romeo and Juliet starring Oilio and Dryliet. The brand supplied the problem. The creator supplied the idea.
The protagonist is the cultural asset. Dr. Max, a Slovak pharmacy brand, partnered with the humour page ZOMRI, whose name means "die", to launch the "Don't Die Bag" of vitamins. It sold out in 24 hours, and the idea would have collapsed with a different creator.
A handy test: take the creator out. If little changes, they’re essentially a media choice. If you lose something distinctive in how the story is told, they’re a creative partner. And if the idea simply wouldn’t work without them, they’re central to the idea itself. That distinction is becoming more important. Among Effie Europe winners, creators as the main touchpoint rose from 7% to 13% between 2024 and 2025.
Follower count is an attribute, not a strategy
Here's an exercise. You have R1 million and three creators. A has 2.8 million followers and broad relevance. B has 240,000 followers and a highly engaged category community. C has 34,000 followers and deep niche authority. Who gets the money?
There's no right answer yet, because you haven't said what you're trying to achieve, who you need to reach, or what each creator costs. If you need broad reach, look at audience scale and fit, and check credibility. If you need platform-native creativity, look at creative capability and check brand linkage. If you want to take part in culture, look at community meaning and check values alignment.
In our recent webinar, More than a like: Brand building in the creator era, we spoke to Lorraine Landon from Google and Sadika Fakir from Absa (who is also a creator herself), and both pushed in this direction. Think of your creators like a media plan, with different people doing different jobs. And in South Africa, credibility isn't just about being local. It's about cultural fluency, understanding the nuances of the community you're speaking to.
Brief the job, not every word
We've all seen the brief: here's the product, the script, the call to action and the hashtags. Please be authentic. You can't approve spontaneity in advance. But "do whatever you want" isn't creative freedom either, it's a missing brief.
The middle ground is controlling the job rather than every creative choice. Be clear on who you need to reach, what they should take away, why the product matters, and which brand or compliance requirements are non-negotiable. Then let the creator work out how that plays in their world.
The branding challenge is real. Compared with other digital advertising, creator content scores well on active involvement (+12 percentile points), relevance (+8) and enjoyment (+6). On branding it scores 7 points lower. And only 27% of creator content links to the brand, according to Kantar's Context Lab. The brand ends up feeling like a guest appearance.
Two fixes stand out.
Say the name out loud. When creators mention the brand in the audio, brand linkage rises by an average of 22%. Only about half of the content analysed did it, often leaving the brand to a caption.
Give the creator a product truth. We found that communicating a product benefit is linked to an 18-point advantage in Brand Power, and when creators demonstrate the product function that led to a 17-point advantage. So instead of ‘make us a fun video’, give the creator a clear reason for why the product matters. What does it do? What problem does it solve? What makes it genuinely different? Then let them turn that truth into something their audience wants to watch. The CeraVe Romeo and Juliette TikTok from Anwar is a perfect example, and the starting point is rooted in the “what’s in for me” for the consumer.
Diagnose before you scale
Say you have 30 creator assets in market. Six are flying on engagement, twelve are doing okay and twelve aren't. The obvious move is to back the six. The better move is to check what each is doing for the brand. A quieter post might have stronger brand potential, and a popular one might need better branding before you amplify it.
Treat every asset as one of three calls: back it, build on it, or rethink it. "Rethink" isn't a verdict on the creator. You're judging a piece of content against a brand job.
The upside is there. Creator content delivers average top-of-mind awareness of 15.7 against 14.0 for other digital advertising, and consideration of 3.4 against 1.9. The job is making that more consistent.
Your creator game plan
1. Know the job. Are we buying reach, relevance or cultural resonance?
2. Protect the magic. When briefing the creator, give them a clear outcome and a meaningful brand role, without scripting away their contribution.
3. Don't confuse attention with impact. Winning the feed isn't the same as winning for your brand. Engagement matters, but it’s not the whole answer.
4. Back the right work. Use evidence to decide what to scale, improve or rethink.
We can still like the likes. We just shouldn't let them run the marketing department.
Download The Creator Game Plan, Kantar's CMO guide to creator effectiveness
Kantar can help you evaluate your creator content through LINK AI so you can make better, more consistent decisions about creator content, so you know what to back, refine or stop earlier, and scale investment with greater confidence.
Join the conversation, follow us on LinkedIn and [[https://twitter.com/Kantar_AME X] for the intelligence behind brand growth in the AI era.