News

Industries

Companies

Jobs

Events

People

Video

Audio

Galleries

Submit content

My Account

Advertise with us

7 payroll outsourcing myths — and the questions business owners should ask instead

When businesses consider outsourcing payroll, they often have sensible concerns. They want to know who will have access to employee information, whether they will still have control and what happens if a mistake is made.
Image source: wrightstudio –
Image source: wrightstudio – 123RF.com

Over the years, I have also heard assumptions that can make it difficult for businesses to judge whether outsourcing would actually work for them.

Here are seven worth looking at more closely:

Myth 1: "We’ll lose control of our payroll"

Outsourcing changes who carries out the work. Your business still makes decisions about its employees, supplies and approves payroll information, and decides who can authorise payment.

The level of control you retain should be clear in your agreement with the provider. Ask what reports you will receive, when you will review the payroll and who must approve it before payment. A good process gives both parties a clear view of their responsibilities.

Myth 2: "Payroll outsourcing is only for large businesses"

The question is not simply how many people you employ but rather whether you have the time, skills and capacity to manage payroll in-house.

A smaller business may rely on an owner or finance manager who has many other responsibilities. A larger business may have a dedicated team but need additional support, continuity or help across several markets.

Myth 3: "It will always cost more than doing it ourselves"

You can only make that comparison once you know what your internal process costs. Software is one part of the picture, but staff time, training, cover for absences and the work involved in resolving errors also deserve consideration.

Request a quote and ask what it includes. Then, also find out whether there is an implementation fee and whether particular services or changes carry an additional charge.

Outsourcing may cost more for some businesses and make financial sense for others. The decision depends on your payroll and the service you need.

Myth 4: "Our employee data won’t be safe"

Payroll information is sensitive, so this concern should never be brushed aside. Whether payroll is managed internally or by a provider, the business needs to understand how access to that information is controlled.

Ask a prospective provider who can access employee records, how information is transferred and what safeguards they use. You should also understand your own team’s responsibilities when sharing payroll inputs and approving access.

Choose a provider that can explain its approach clearly and answer your questions.

Myth 5: "An external provider won’t understand our people"

A payroll provider needs to understand how your business works, which includes everything from your pay cycle, your approval process, the information you need and how queries should be handled. That understanding comes from a working relationship and clear communication.

Before choosing a provider, ask who will manage your account and how you will reach them. Find out who handles the day-to-day payroll and who reviews it.

Myth 6: "Once we outsource, payroll is entirely the provider’s responsibility"

A provider can take on the agreed payroll work, but your business still has responsibilities as an employer.

For example, your team needs to supply accurate information and communicate changes on time. You also need to understand who reviews payroll, who approves payment and who is responsible for each statutory task.

Ask for those duties in writing before the service begins. If something is unclear, resolve it early rather than waiting for a deadline or an employee query.

Myth 7: "Switching providers will be a nightmare"

Moving payroll takes planning. Employee records need to be checked, responsibilities assigned and the timing agreed so that the business can continue to pay its people.

The process should not be left to chance. Ask a prospective provider what information they need, who will manage implementation and how they will check that the new payroll reflects your agreed requirements. It is also worth asking how they handle questions during the first few pay cycles.

An implementation fee may apply, so include it when you compare quotes.

Ask the questions that matter to your business

I would rather ask difficult questions before appointing a payroll provider than discover a misunderstanding after the first payroll has run.

You should know what the service includes, how your data will be handled, who will review the payroll and who you can contact when you need help. Those answers will tell you far more than a broad promise about outsourcing.

About Anton van Heerden

Anton Van Heerden is the managing director for DNA Outsourcing & DNA EOR
More news
Let's do Biz