News

Industries

Companies

Jobs

Events

People

Video

Audio

Galleries

Submit content

My Account

Advertise with us

How do marketers balance brand and performance spend?

Marketers* are not choosing between brand and performance. Their current split is close to even, and most believe both work. What they want is a clearer view of how.
How do marketers balance brand and performance spend? (Image source: © 123rf )
How do marketers balance brand and performance spend? (Image source: © 123rf 123rf)

Brand tracking has become a habit.

In recent IAS research among 40 marketers, 85% said they run brand tracking studies, and most do so regularly. The result was an encouraging one for Johanna McDowell, CEO of the Independent Agency Search & Selection Company (IAS).

“Marketers are clearly committed to understanding how their brands are doing,” she says.

The research, The Growth Equation, explored how marketers balance brand and performance spend. Brand measurement is the settled half of that story. Performance is where the questions begin.

Brand tracking is established

Most trackers are brand health studies, often supplemented by market share or business metrics. Awareness remains a core measure, and purchase intent has risen to match it.

Nearly one in five marketers plan to start measuring intent, with some planning to build AI models to do so.

Frequency is the soft spot. Most studies run annually or twice a year, which contradicts the “always on” thinking the industry champions.

How do marketers balance brand and performance spend?

Performance marketing has plenty of numbers

Cost per acquisition, cost per lead and click-through rate lead the performance metrics, each measured by roughly two-thirds of respondents.

Customer lifetime value is the one to watch. Only about a third measure it today, but many of the rest see it as a future priority.

Who supplies the numbers?

Much of the data behind performance reporting comes from those doing the work. The platforms supply the analytics and the media agencies supply the metrics.

That isn’t a charge of inaccuracy.

Every media owner has a perspective, and the numbers can reflect it. A broadcaster and a media agency will often tell different awareness stories, because each has something different at stake.

The data itself is not in dispute. A click is a click. What varies is how it is read, and anyone who recommended a channel has a stake in its success.

Measurability adds a further wrinkle. Marketers value being able to attribute results, but many see budgets drifting toward what can be counted and away from what is harder to prove, such as brand equity, emotional connection and long-term consumer trust.

Many marketers are frustrated by reports full of impressive-sounding figures that can’t be tied to business outcomes.

As McDowell puts it, a marketer can be told there are a million likes on Facebook, but “what does that actually mean?”

The space in between

Brand tracking does reflect the effect of performance activity, but indirectly and late. It shows that awareness, sentiment and intent have moved, not which channels moved them, and results arrive six to 12 months after the spend. Performance teams, meanwhile, optimise continuously and see results within minutes.

Between the instant metric and the long-range tracker sits a gap.

McDowell questions whether something independent could fill it, perhaps drawing on research houses that could offer a different reading of the same platform data. There is no answer yet, but it is, she suggests, worth exploring.

Senior marketers delegate the machinery

Most respondents were senior, and most leave optimisation tools to their teams and agencies.

Although a sensible division of labour, it does mean dashboards alone may not give leaders the accountability they want.

One response came from a recent IAS masterclass, where a leading telecoms company described building performance expertise inside its own marketing team.

The aim is not to second-guess agencies but to understand the channels well enough to engage with their recommendations rather than simply to follow them.

For now, independent interpretation of performance metrics is an open question, but one the industry may be well placed to answer.

(* Marketers: respondents in the research)

Let's do Biz