The 2025 trade tensions between China and the United States revived a familiar claim: consumers could buy luxury or premium goods directly from Chinese factories for a fraction of their retail price.
Amid uncertainty surrounding tariffs and supply chains, viral videos on platforms such as TikTok claimed that Chinese factories producing goods for Western brands, including prestigious fashion houses, could manufacture and sell those products directly to consumers.
The question is whether goods manufactured by businesses with full knowledge of a brand’s designs, materials, production methods, or supply chain constitute counterfeit goods.
Counterfeit Goods Act: Authority at the point of manufacture
In the South African legal context, whether a product is counterfeit or not depends not on the factory’s location in China, its history of manufacturing for the brand owner, or how closely the item resembles an authentic product.
The key issue is whether the goods were manufactured or produced, using, embodying or sold in association with, the intellectual property of the brand owner, and whether the conduct infringes that right.
Martine Vogelman 6 Jul 2026 The Counterfeit Goods Act addresses the production of goods that imitate protected goods without the authority of the relevant intellectual property owner. The definition of “counterfeiting” includes the following:
Without the authority of the owner of any intellectual property right subsisting in the Republic in respect of protected goods, the manufacturing, producing or making, whether in the Republic or elsewhere, of any goods whereby those protected goods are imitated in such manner and to such a degree that those other goods are substantially identical copies of the protected goods.
Unlawful activity in terms of the Counterfeit Goods Act is therefore not confined to activities resulting in a crude imitation from an unrelated workshop. The provisions may apply to a highly convincing copy produced by a manufacturer familiar with a brand’s specifications.
A manufacturer’s authority is generally limited by the purchase order, agreed quantity, quality-control procedures and contractual terms. For example, permission to manufacture 10,000 units does not, by itself, extend to producing another 500 units for independent sale.
Such goods will constitute “counterfeit goods”, and even a seemingly flawless batch made outside the contract will be counterfeit if the brand owner did not authorise the use of its intellectual property to make those specific goods.
The Trade Marks Act: The principle of trade mark exhaustion
What is often confused with instances of counterfeiting is section 34(2)(d) of the Trade Marks Act 194 of 1993, which limits a trade mark proprietor’s infringement rights.
This section provides that a registered trade mark is not infringed by the importation, distribution or sale in South Africa of goods to which the mark has been applied by or with the consent of the trade mark proprietor.
Aletia Oberholster 26 Jun 2025 The provision embodies the principle of trade mark exhaustion: once genuine goods bearing a trade mark have been placed on the market with the trade mark proprietor’s consent, the later resale of those same goods is not trade mark infringement merely because it occurs outside the trade mark proprietor’s preferred distribution network.
This is why a genuine item released by a brand abroad may sometimes be imported and resold in South Africa as a parallel import, or “grey good”.
The importer need not be authorised, but the goods must be genuine in the relevant legal sense: the trade mark on the goods must have been applied by, or with the consent of, the trade mark proprietor.
Distinction between the two provisions
The distinction is clear. The Counterfeit Goods Act addresses the unauthorised production of goods that unlawfully imitate protected goods, with a lack of authority at its core.
By contrast, once a trade mark proprietor has consented to production, section 34(2)(d) of the Trade Marks Act protects the subsequent trade in genuine goods on the basis that the trade mark proprietor consented to their production.
Exhaustion does not legitimise unauthorised manufacture.
A relationship with a factory does not imply consent to every unit it produces; such consent must relate to the application of the mark to the particular goods concerned.
Nishaat Slamdien 26 Nov 2024 This is clearly illustrated in the following scenarios:
- Where a genuine, branded jacket sold abroad with the trade mark proprietor’s consent is imported into South Africa by an independent reseller, section 34(2)(d) may protect that resale even though the reseller is outside the official distribution network.
- Where a supplier manufactures an off-contract batch and applies the trade mark without permission, the exhaustion defence is unavailable; if the goods imitate protected goods to the relevant degree, such goods constitute “counterfeit goods” in terms of the Counterfeit Goods Act.
- Where an unbranded lookalike product is manufactured and sold by a supplier that the trade mark proprietor uses for the production of the genuine goods, then this may give rise to other intellectual property enforcement options such as passing off, but it does not automatically make the product counterfeit.
In conclusion, these disputes depend on the evidence in each case, including the terms of the manufacturing agreement and whether production overruns were permitted.
The key principle, however, is clear: being produced in the “same factory” is not sufficient.
What matters is whether the trade mark proprietor authorised the production and application of the trade mark to the goods in question.