Employees who have been awarded reinstatement and have validly offered to return to work, do not have to repeat that offer after their employer’s court challenges have ended. Once the suspension of enforcement is lifted, the employer must honour that existing offer and reinstate them.
This was the Labour Appeal Court's (LAC) recent judgment in Ni-Da Transport (Pty) Ltd and Another v AMCU obo Fakude and 211 Others after a seven-year legal process. The judgment confirms that review and appeal proceedings may suspend enforcement of a reinstatement award, but do not cancel an employee’s earlier valid offer to return to work, legally known as a “tender of services”.
Background and the initial tender of services
On 6 March 2019, a bargaining council arbitrator found that Ni-Da Transport (Ni-Da) had unfairly dismissed 127 employees, whose services had been engaged through a temporary employment services provider, and ordered their reinstatement. In terms of the arbitration award, the employees were required to tender their services within 10 days of the award being served.
On 29 March 2019, 58 of the employees arrived at Ni-Da's premises and offered to return to work. Ni-Da refused their offer and subsequently instituted review proceedings challenging the award. It also furnished security, thereby suspending enforcement of the award.
Bradley Workman-Davies 21 Aug 2026 Years of appeals and contempt proceedings
The Labour Court dismissed the review on 25 May 2022, and a petition for leave to appeal was refused by the LAC on 15 February 2023. Ni-Da then approached the Constitutional Court with an application for leave to appeal, which was also refused on 29 September 2023.
The parties engaged in settlement negotiations which broke down on 7 February 2024. The union demanded compliance with the arbitration award and, in particular, that Ni-Da reinstate the employees. Ni-Da refused, arguing that the employees should have retendered their services within 10 days of the Constitutional Court’s order. This led to the employees seeking to enforce the award through contempt proceedings at the Labour Court.
Labour Court ruling
The Labour Court found that the 58 employees had already validly tendered their services within the prescribed period (back in March 2019) and were not required to re-tender following the conclusion of Ni-Da's legal challenges.
It further held that Ni-Da bore a positive obligation to facilitate the 58 employees' reinstatement once its legal remedies had been exhausted. Ni-Da's failure to take proactive steps to reinstate the employees consequently resulted in a finding of contempt.
LAC findings
On appeal, the LAC agreed that the employees were not required to repeat their tender of services. The court found that review and appeal proceedings suspended enforcement of the arbitration award but did not cancel an earlier valid offer to return to work or extinguish the rights arising from it. A valid tender of services remains effective throughout the suspension, regardless of how long the employer’s legal challenges take.
The court determined that requiring the employees to offer to return to work again would effectively penalise them for delays arising from the employer's decision to pursue its legal remedies, even though they had already complied with the arbitration award. The fact that the award had not been certified when the employees tendered their services, did not invalidate their tender.
Acceptance is mandatory, even if facilitation is not
On whether an employer bears a positive obligation to facilitate reinstatement, the LAC found that while this may be good industrial relations practice, there was no legal basis for such an obligation.
Referring to the Constitutional Court's judgment in Numsa on behalf of Fohlisa & Others v Hendor Mining Supplies, the LAC reaffirmed that employees must choose to take up reinstatement by offering to return to work.
However, once an employee has validly tendered their services, the employer must accept that existing tender and reinstate them when its legal challenges have been exhausted and the suspension of enforcement has been lifted.
The LAC accordingly dismissed Ni-Da's appeal and upheld the finding of contempt.
Key takeaways for employers and employees
This judgment serves as an important reminder that employers may lawfully refuse a tender of services while review or appeal proceedings are pending, however, during the suspension period, the integrity of the award remains unaffected and intact. Once the suspension lifts, the position reverts and the employer must implement the award, failing which, it risks contempt. While there is no legal duty to actively facilitate reinstatement, doing so may be sensible practice.
For employees, this judgment highlights the importance of validly offering to return to work in accordance with the reinstatement award. Once they have done so, they do not need to repeat that offer simply because the employer has pursued review or appeal proceedings.