News

Industries

Companies

Jobs

Events

People

Video

Audio

Galleries

Submit content

My Account

Advertise with us

Self-employed South Africans face a home loan system stacked against them

South Africa’s entrepreneurs are helping sustain the economy, create jobs and drive business growth, yet securing finance to buy a home remains disproportionately difficult.
Source: Supplied.
Source: Supplied.

Unlike salaried employees, self-employed applicants face more complex home loan processes, extensive documentation requirements and stricter affordability assessments.

Hannah van Deventer, national director of Phoenix Bonds, argues that outdated bank lending models are penalising successful business owners, despite their contribution to economic resilience, and calls for a more balanced approach to assessing their financial health and home loan affordability.

“The irony is that while the government is creating massive policy initiatives through the National Treasury and the Presidency to prioritise micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs), the banks regard them as high-risk. Entrepreneurs have to wade through outdated credit models that rarely apply to salary earners. Surely the banks should be backing successful business owners with strong financial records, rather than penalising them?”

Entrepreneurs and the job crisis

The barrier to property finance for the self-employed is even more dramatic when contrasted against South Africa's current macroeconomy: the Statistics South Africa Quarterly Labour Force Survey puts national official unemployment at a staggering 33.6%, and youth unemployment at 47.4%.

"Formal SMMEs are responsible for roughly 60% of all employment in South Africa. Entrepreneurs are literally keeping the country working, yet traditional banking systems are treating them as high-risk,” Van Deventer states.

The paperwork gauntlet

While salaried applicants can generally substantiate their income with payslips and bank statements, self-employed applicants face what Van Deventer calls “an administrative gauntlet”.

“The latest FNB Property Barometer shows that the homeloan rejection rate for self-employed individuals is approximately 15% higher than that of salaried workers. And general market indicators show that banks routinely demand cash deposits of 10 to 20% from entrepreneurs, a stark contrast to corporate employees who regularly qualify for 100%, zero-deposit home loans.

“When you read this in conjunction with Standard Bank data which shows that self-employed homeloan registrations have risen by 33%, there’s a gaping contradiction.

"Strong non-salaried buyers are entering the property market in droves, but the application processes are still heavily weighted against them. Banks frequently require two years of audited annual financial statements, current management accounts, personal and business bank statements, tax assessments, and additional confirmation from certified accountants,” she explains.

“And even after submitting a mountain of paperwork, they are often asked for more. What’s particularly frustrating is that even an official ITA34 issued by Sars isn’t always enough to satisfy a bank’s rigid verification criteria.”

Nobody is suggesting that banks should abandon responsible lending practices under the National Credit Act, she asserts. “But there needs to be a balance. The level of documentation required must be proportionate to the actual risk, rather than creating an entry barrier for anyone who doesn't earn a conventional salary.”

Cash flow vs payslips

One of the blind spots in the credit-assessment process is how entrepreneurs manage their cash flow, says Van Deventer. Unlike employees who receive fixed monthly salaries, a business owner's income is often a hybrid combination of salary, dividends, and drawings.

“Further, many successful business owners limit their personal drawings to preserve working capital or reinvest profits into growing their companies.” she adds.

“They may be operating a profitable company, employing multiple people, and have a healthy balance sheet, but that doesn't mean they can show a massive monthly salary in their personal statements. Banks need to look at the combined financial health of both the individual and the business to understand sustainable affordability.”

Another major obstacle, she continues, is the disconnect between the way accountants prepare financials and the way credit departments analyse them. “Accountants focus on optimising tax efficiency; banks look strictly through the lens of individual debt-servicing capability.”

The line between approval and decline: Regularly approached by self-employed applicants who have been turned down by their own banks, Van Deventer says when they review the documents, the issue isn’t always about a lack of affordability but rather without the contextual narrative a credit assessor needs to understand that specific business model.

“Detailed motivations, clear explanations of business income cycles, and fully reconciled figures can make all the difference,” she emphasises.

Calling on South African banks to modernise their assessment models to reflect the growing gig and entrepreneurial economy, Van Deventer concludes: “We cannot encourage South Africans to become brave entrepreneurs on one hand, and then lock them out of the property market with the other.

"Our lending processes have to evolve to accommodate the people who are driving our economic future.”

Let's do Biz