Competitors certainly do, but of course that often requires adjustments to offensive and defensive business postures. More satisfying is the carefully assembled research by consultancies and think-tanks which dovetails perfectly with what we do every day. It is always a welcome affirmation.
We came across one recently. It was a report written by the German company Porsche Consulting. In case you are wondering, they were indeed the internal consulting arm of the sports car company, advising on all manner of vehicle related matters within Porsche. They were spun out as an independent consultancy in 1993, initially in the automotive industry, but now widely spread across many sectors, with 950 consultants employed globally.
A few weeks ago they dropped a 26-page report titled “Security Tokenization – How to unlock hidden value by moving stocks, bonds, and funds on the blockchain”
So naturally we looked, as we always do when knowledgeable people write about our sector. The extensively footnoted report read like it had been commissioned and approved by us. Of course, much of the content was very familiar; it is embedded in our corporate DNA. But there was also some clever aggregation of some lesser-known data which we want to share.
The paper begins with a concise articulation of the advantages of security tokenisation – the widening of capital sources for issuers, the broader investment opportunities for buyers, the advantages of tokenisation (security, speed, divisibility, security, trading, tracking, settlement, etc.) These are core songs off our hymn sheet, we sing them often.
But where the paper gets really interesting is in the areas of cost, efficiency and regulation.
The authors take the approach of describing the traditional structure of a capital market issuance in terms of the functions performed – the roles of front, middle and back office in a real-world asset issuance. See their diagram below:
These functions will be familiar to anyone who has worked in traditional financial asset issuance. But the authors use this framework to precisely calculate the achievable cost savings in these functions by scouring the academic literature to gain access to tested metrics. Here is the upshot:
Front Office:
Middle Office:
Back Office:
The paper then breaks down the actual cost savings, the majority of which are found in Middle and Back Office functions (MBO):
Because this report was produced by a German company, the section on regulatory benefits has an EU-flavour. In addition to outlining the landscape of crypto-specific regulation in various EU countries, (with Switzerland being the most crypto-progressive), the authors highlight a more important matter. Current regulations for traditional finance simply become non-issues with tokenised securities.
The examples they provide:
The report ends with a call to action for all financial players participating in capital markets:
It is crucial to develop a target picture, including the ambition level for digital assets as well as the role digital assets can possibly play regarding the company´s business model.
We couldn’t have said it better ourselves.