Media News South Africa

Minister still 'stubborn' on Secrecy Bill changes, protests set to intensify

State security minister Siyabonga Cwele's latest 'stubborn' stance on the much-hated Protection of Information Bill changes has angered right groups and media organisations, which are set to take their loud campaign to Durban and Cape Town this week to protest against the government's unconstitutional attempt to return the country to the apartheid's secretive and autocratic rule.
Minister still 'stubborn' on Secrecy Bill changes, protests set to intensify

"Judging by his ever more desperate attempts at spin, the minister is clearly feeling the heat, but we will not be put off course and we will continue our week of action, culminating in a mass march to Parliament and Durban City Hall [this] Wednesday, October 27," the Right2Know campaign said in a statement.

Cwele claimed in September to have heard the public's concerns and even outlined proposed changes, which critics described as 'cosmetic at best'.

Blew it

But, when he appeared before Parliament's ad-hoc committee last week, he blew it. He categorically rejected the criticism levelled against the bill, calling it illegitimate and stating that the bill in its current form was in line with the Constitution, international human rights charters and conventions, and international best practices.

Cwele said: "Those who continue to argue against the bill, following our proposals on 17 September 2010 and today, are basically of the view that South Africa has no legitimate national security to protect."

Those who oppose the Secrecy Bill argue that the legislation will stifle the free flow of information - the lifeblood of an open, responsive and accountable democracy - and hamper investigative journalism and send SA back to the inferno of apartheid days.

William Bird, of the Media Monitoring Africa (MMA), said on Sunday 24 October: "We regret that both the minister and the state security agency recently refused to supply a copy of the minister's first submission to this same ad-hoc committee. The reason given was that 'disclosure could reasonably be expected to cause prejudice to the defence and security of the republic'.

"Made in public"

"This claim was made despite the fact that the submission presentation was made in public, that its content was widely reported, and that a transcript and recording of the submission were available online. (See www.facebook.com/mediamattersza, entries on 5, 12 and 13 October 2010)."

Bird added: "As the MMA, we believe that there is a real fear that this bill, if enacted, will be used to hide information that government ministers and civil servants may view as embarrassing, damaging or politically difficult.

"Unless there is a real and effective way for people to access and publish information that 'is in the public interest' this proposed legislation would violate rather than protect the rights of South African citizens."

This week's Right2Know campaign protest programme is as follows:

Monday (today):

Cavalcade through central Durban with coffins depicting death of information - departing from Diakonia Centre, at 20 Diakonia Avenue, Durban, at 12 noon).

Film Screening in Cape Town: 'The Most Dangerous Man in America' with Tri Continents Film Festival (Labia on Orange cinema, 68 Orange Street, Gardens, Cape Town at 6.15pm).

Tuesday (tomorrow):

Mock 'book burning' and performance art in Durban at Workshop Amphitheatre (Workshop Shopping Mall, Pine St, Durban Central, 8am-12 noon).

Placard-making session in Cape Town (ISS Office, 2nd Floor, The Armoury, Buchanan Square at 160 Sir Lowry Road, Woodstock at 2pm).

Wentworth Community Meeting (Austerville Community Hall, corner Austerville and Percy Johnstone Road, Austerville, Durban at 6.30pm).

Wednesday:

KwaZulu-Natal: March to City Hall Gathering at Botha's Garden, Julius Nyrere St,Durban at 8am.

Western Cape: Right2Know March to Parliament gathering in Kaizersgracht Street, Cape Town at 9.30am, arriving at Parliament at 12 noon.

For more:

See also:

About Issa Sikiti da Silva

Issa Sikiti da Silva is a winner of the 2010 SADC Media Awards (print category). He freelances for various media outlets, local and foreign, and has travelled extensively across Africa. His work has been published both in French and English. He used to contribute to Bizcommunity.com as a senior news writer.
Let's do Biz