Phew, the digital, mobile and social media space is certainly hotting up recently. There have been more announcements and moves in this space than you can shake a stick at. And, while this is all very exciting and it's great to see such buoyancy after 2009's doom and gloom, as a PR and communications consultant, I am feeling a touch of unease.
Primarily, I am concerned about unrealistic expectations being set up with clients by agencies, often followed by poor implementation by people who haven't truly engaged in the space for a significant period of time. I fear this disjoint will ultimately lead to the PR and communications industry being given a bad name - as it was by the champagne-and-stilettos brigade in the 1990s.
Not only that, though, if South African companies don't get this social, mobile and digital media thing right, they will lose the biggest opportunity they have to grow their businesses and be successful.
Things that have made me raise a sceptical eyebrow recently include:
What's with the silo approach?
Certainly, the announcement of a new division gets an agency attention, but just how does it work to have all your social media “rock stars” sitting at one end of the agency when it comes to running integrated communication campaigns?
Social media, online and mobile needs to be considered at strategy and conceptualisation stage, and then implemented coherently across the board. At MANGO-OMC we're seeing more and more that we are required to take both a strategic and project manager role on behalf of our clients, bringing together different communication channels and technologies, overseeing an integrated campaign and serving as chief gatekeeper for brand messages.
Huh? A community manager that sits outside the company they represent?
It is highly, highly unlikely that an agency will know your company as well as you do. And, given that one of the key requirements for a successful social media engagement is authenticity, you're stumbling before you are even out the box if your agency convinces you that it can look after this function.
What your agency can do, however, is work with you on strategy, set in place the foundations of effective social media engagement with the customers in your target market, and guide and coach you on maintaining an effective and successful conversation.
Social media experts with 25 Twitter followers and 10 tweets?
Imagine walking into a Hell's Angels convention wearing a pink pleather jacket and carrying a scooter helmet with the price tag still attached. And expecting to be taken seriously. Not going to happen.
It's the same thing with social media; you only truly understand the space and engage authentically if you are genuinely part of it in your own capacity. Else at best you are going to get ignored, but more likely laughed at and then ignored.
Over-emphasising the impact of social and digital media in South Africa.
Get real. Yes, it's a rapidly growing wave, and, yes, you almost definitely need to get on it. But throw out everything else you are doing? Probably not.
Let's take a look at some numbers: 2.3 million South Africans are active Facebook users every month; 467 500 South Africans have a Twitter account; and 5.3 Million South Africans have Internet access. But amongst our population of more than 47 million, traditional media blows these stats out the water.
Umhlobo Wenene FM has 4.3 million listeners a week, and The Sowetan, a regional newspaper, has more than 2 million readers a day. So, decide whom you want to reach, and find out where they are actively engaging, rather than jumping on the latest and most edgy fad.
What is key, though, is to maximise all your communications and PR efforts by integrating and amplifying them across the various channels you have chosen.
Don't forget about mobile.
And I don't mean mobile Internet only: according to Arthur Goldstuck from World Wide Worx there are 50 million mobile phone connections in South Africa, and about 36 million individual subscribers.
There are heaps of cool, interactive things you can do with a bog standard mobile phone. Just tread carefully, as South Africans have been bitten one too many times by unscrupulous subscription offers.
And make sure that what is happening on the mobile phone is aligned with what is happening in the rest of the campaign.
This is too important an opportunity to get things wrong. Agencies, start eating your own dog food.
And South African companies, notch up the scepticism a few levels the next time you are speaking to the latest social media rock star.
Catherine Lückhoff is a founding member and joint partner at Mango-OMC (www.mango-omc.com, a maverick communications agency that specialises in truly integrated public relations, media relations, branding and communications campaigns. A skilled strategist, Catherine conceptualises creative and effective communications blueprints for her clients, and then pulls together the right team to implement the programme. Clients include Rocking the Daisies Music Festival; Red Bull; DStv Online (including DStv.com, SuperSport.com, MNet.co.za, VUZU.tv and TheAfricanFilmLibrary.com); Cape Town Routes Unlimited; Red Bull; Woolworths Financial Services; and Shake Interactive. Contact Catherine on tel +27 (0)21 461 9244, email her , reader her blog at www.cluckhoff.com and follow her on Twitter at @cluckhoff.
Jason Steele
The truth hurts-
Catherine,
Great article and very true across the board, get to know the space before you try and make an impression. Posted on 19 Apr 2010 14:31
Advertising agencies need to realize that the way the work, what they produce and who drives the creative process (and ultimately, the implementation of campaigns) does not rest with them alone. PR practitioners are the logical overseers of social media campaigns, but more collaboration is required. A new reality is emerging that will challenge ad agencies demanding top dollar for campaigns, but in order to demand more of the budgets recklessly handed out to ad agencies for traditional ads (TV, especially), PR types need to execute and demonstrate measurable results. As Bob once sang, the times they are achangin'... Posted on 19 Apr 2010 15:22
i so completely agree - try linking to any of your clients via social media and it shows immediately if they are comfortable or not (let alone understand the possibilities)
eating dog food is difficult! Posted on 20 Apr 2010 09:10
You are so on the money Catherine. I work for the largest watch and fragrance importer into SA and we are encouraged to use all our products. We are given products to wear and use, but yet are never asked to actively promote the products - we just want to as we appreciate and enjoy the products - we believe in the products. Posted on 20 Apr 2010 09:14
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.
Angola
Botswana
Malawi
Mozambique
Namibia
Zimbabwe
Cote D'Ivoire
Ghana
Nigeria
Kenya
Uganda
Tanzania
Mauritius
Seychelles
Algeria
Egypt
Morocco
Zambia
Primarily, I am concerned about unrealistic expectations being set up with clients by agencies, often followed by poor implementation by people who haven't truly engaged in the space for a significant period of time. I fear this disjoint will ultimately lead to the PR and communications industry being given a bad name - as it was by the champagne-and-stilettos brigade in the 1990s.
