The proposed amendments to the Labour Relations Act are set to force broadcasting and media houses to re-look their business models and employment practices. Employers like the SABC are heavily reliant on freelancers, contract and short-term employees.
On 17 December 2010, the Department of Labour published various amendments to the Labour Relations Act of 1995 (the Bill). The Bill seeks to avoid exploitation of workers, ensure decent work for all workers, as well as to protect the employment relationship. Further, the Bill intends to introduce provisions to regulate contract work, sub-contracting, outsourcing and labour broking.
The main proposed amendments intend to require employers to recruit employees on a permanent basis, unless there is a valid reason to employ personnel on a short-term or temporary basis.
Vulnerable workers to receive protection
According to the explanatory memorandum to the Bill, the legislature intends to ensure that vulnerable categories of workers receive adequate protection and are employed in conditions of decent work. It is proposed that this amendment shall only apply to employees who are below a threshold set by the minister of labour. As a result, the amendment will not impact on the use of fixed-term contracts with respect to managerial and other senior employees.
Another controversial proposed amendment is the intention by the legislature to exclude employees earning more than the prescribed threshold from referring their labour disputes to the CCMA. The minister of labour shall publish regulations to exclude employees earning a prescribed remuneration from utilising the CCMA. This move, according to the Bill, will ensure that vulnerable employees are not prejudiced because of delays caused by the volume of complaints from employees who can afford to approach the courts.
Implications for the media, broadcasting market
In order to fully understand the implications of the proposed amendments, it is critical to scan the media and broadcasting labour market. The SABC employs over 3000 personnel across the nine provinces. A significant number of radio presenters and TV news anchors are either employed as freelancers or on a short-term fixed contract.
The public broadcaster has with respect to several well-reported labour disputes terminated freelancers' contracts or did not renew those contracts without detailed and convincing reasons. Further, some positions are on freelance basis without clear reasons. A complicating factor for the public broadcaster shall apply to personnel who hold multiple freelance and short-term positions with different salaries.
If the Bill is approved this status quo shall have to change with serious consequences to the employees involved. Due to the increased local content requirements imposed by the regulator ICASA, the SABC staff head count ballooned, with a number of freelancers and short-tem employees being added to the public broadcaster payroll. The local content requirements partially led to the SABC financial crisis and the closure or liquidation of more than 200 production companies and retrenchments emanating thereof.
Revising budgetary requirements
Freelancers and short-term employees generally do not receive benefits such as medical aid, pension or training from their employers. If the Labour Relations Amendment Bill is approved by parliament and enacted by the president in its current form, the SABC and other media houses, particularly newspapers and magazines, shall be required to revise their budgetary requirements to take into account benefits such as medical aid and pension.
The impact of the Bill on employers shall be to conduct a skills audit and business re-engineering process, to assess critical skills needed to conduct the business, and do a cost-cutting measure by restructuring and reducing staff complement. It is within this context that the proposed amendment that will require employers to employ personnel on a permanent basis, will shake employers like the SABC, as the labour reforms will require programming departments of stations like Metro FM and 5FM, to take a long -term view when conceptualising their programming strategies, formulating the presenters line-up and negotiating presenters' contracts.
Broadcasters and other media houses business models survive on employing staff on short-term or freelance contracts due to reliance on sometimes unpredictable advertising revenue. With many broadcasters and media companies still recovering from the economic recession and declining advertising revenue, while the amendments will have benefits to employees' job security, employers will be forced to take a critical look at the kind of employees they want to recruit and retain.
It will therefore need new business strategies for the proposed labour reforms not to choke the broadcasting and media sectors. Public comments on the proposed amendment close on the Thursday, 17 February 2011.
Avhasei Mukoma is chairman of Mukoma Attorneys (www.mukomaattorneys.co.za). He is writing a book on competition in broadcasting and telecommunications industries in South Africa. Email him at . He writes in his personal capacity.
labour reforms to rock media in more ways than one-
The SABC and others here are not unique. No broadcaster - including the likes of HBS- who made the Soccer World Cup broadcasts possible - can operate without freelance operators. This is due to the nature of the game with its peaks and lows.Whether there is good or bad advertising income is immaterial. The World Cup is a good case in point where a lot of experts were required at a given place for a relatively short period and then immediately therafter, nothing. The number of permanent staff with their perks etc as prescribed by law, required to handle the peaks will bancrupt any business. Operationally speaking it is also a nightmare to accommodate that high staff number during the low peaks. During the SABC's woes it abused the fact that freelancers are not protected by law and in many cases unilaterallly lowered the fees paid to those freelancers that they could not do without. On top of that the fees had been frozen for two years now, going for three. In the meantime it has given its staff yearly increases and the people at the top still get their millions. Many of these freelancers with unique skills will in the technocratic environment of broadcasting and film and other media I surmise, have to be paid yearly salaries equal and more than that of many managers. Who can afford that if you don't have work for them all the time? Thus, if the bill goes through it will have a threefold effect - put more local freelancers out of work, force lower salaries for permanent operational staff and force companies to cut the number of bureaucrats ( see the end credits of SABC programmes compared to ten years ago). As the bureaucrats will have to implement - the latter step is the least likely to happen - at the SABC in any case.So the proposed Bill is an improvement in our labour law? Posted on 9 Feb 2011 10:17
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. defamation, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.