Advertising News South Africa

Clients choose top performing ad agencies in 2005

At last, clients have the final say. South Africa's best performing advertising agency in 2005 was Sorcery Outsourced, while TBWA Hunt Lascaris (Durban) took the laurels in the international agencies category, according to a study by Objectivity.

The results are based on the quantified perceptions of the agencies' clients in the Top Performing Advertising Agencies perception study conducted by Objectivity, a perception measurement and management company.

This is the second year that Objectivity has released the results of the annual study it has conducted for more than two decades. Previously the findings were shared only with the agency concerned or used to aid clients of the company's advertising agency selection service.

"We took the decision to release the results in the interests of furthering Objectivity's corporate vision, which is to 'make marketing, and other forms of communication, a quantifiable discipline'," said Clive Webster, Senior Partner of Objectivity.

"By publicising the achievements and efforts of those agencies that are fulfilling the real needs and wants of their clients, we hope to encourage the pursuit of quality, creative advertising that yields a quantifiable return on clients' investments, over the pursuit of creativity for its own sake."

The 2005 study revealed that advertisers ranked professionalism and reliability above creativity for the third year in a row, while their desired standards of performance declined for the second consecutive year.

Objectivity awarded certificates to the top 10 agencies in each criterion and introduced trophies for the two overall 'Best Performing Agencies'.

Webster concludes: "The creatives have spoken; the analysts, critics and judges have spoken; and now at last the advertisers, whose money is being spent, have the final word."

Here are the names and scores of the top agencies in six categories that reflect advertisers' most important criteria when selecting and using an advertising agency...

RankSouth AfricanScoreRankInternationalScore
Criterion 1: Professional/Reliable. (Importance Index: 100. Desired Standard: 5.5)
1Sorcery Outsourced8041Saatchi & Saatchi - Cape670
2Lara7612TBWA Hunt Lascaris - Dbn668
3Pie Street7543Wunderman641
Criterion 2: Creativity (Importance Index: 73. Desired Standard: 5.8)
1Sorcery Outsourced11221TBWA Hunt Lascaris - Dbn1017
2Pie Street10782Saatchi & Saatchi - Cape981
3Lara10733Wunderman974
Criterion 3: Client Knowledge/Understanding (Importance Index: 60. Desired Standard: 5.8)
1Sorcery Outsourced3381Saatchi & Saatchi - Cape307
2Lara3222TBWA Hunt Lascaris - Dbn303
3Pie Street3203Red Nail298
Criterion 4: Strategic Planning (Importance Index: 59. Desired Standard: 5.6)
1Sorcery Outsourced5381Saatchi & Saatchi - Cape486
2Pie Street5032Wunderman461
3Lara4963TBWA Hunt Lascaris - Dbn453
Criterion 5: Cost Effective/Effective (Importance Index: 28. Desired Standard: 5.5)
1Pie Street4621TBWA Hunt Lascaris - Dbn416
2Sorcery Outsourced4502Saatchi & Saatchi - Cape399
3Roots - Dbn4333DDB388
Criterion 6: People/Relationships (Importance Index: 28. Desired Standard: 5.7)
1Lara3411TBWA Hunt Lascaris - Dbn328
2Pie Street3382Saatchi & Saatchi - Cape324
3Sorcery Outsourced3383Wunderman315

Let's do Biz