"We need to investigate, report, provide a platform for debate, not constitute a new lobby," tweeted Dawes
, later adding (among other tweets) that "laws that attack us as journalists require us to respond as journalists. Doesn't mean we mobilise on all matters of controversy."
Stuck to his gunsAbramjee
stuck to his guns, arguing that journalists are members of society, too, and there is nothing wrong with them campaigning on issues that concern the citizens of our country. If we campaign against the Secrecy Bill
, for instance, then why should we not campaign on other issues that do not directly concern journalism?
Abramjee, who is also head of the Lead SA
initiative, is an energetic and passionate campaigner. There are some who are uncomfortable
with how the Primedia radio stations, Talk Radio 702 and Cape Talk, cover his campaigns and also question
for whom he speaks with his National Press Club
His let's-get-stuck-in-and-change-things attitude is infectious and let's not forget that South African journalism has a strong activist history. In the apartheid era, the journalists and editors of liberal newspapers such as the Rand Daily Mail
, Cape Times
and Daily Dispatch
went far beyond the call of duty to fight the regime.
Shouldn't just sit on the fence
One can also argue that journalists shouldn't just sit on the fence and that newspapers need to campaign more for their communities of readers to remain relevant.
But I'm with Dawes on this issue as I believe there is a fine line between reporting objectively on controversial issues and becoming involved. You step over that line and you find it harder to defend your objectivity. The tolls issue is also a complex problem, not a straightforward case of holding the authorities accountable for service-delivery promises.
Like lawyers and priests, journalists work at an intersection of society, where we meet a wide range of people - from the very rich to the very poor - and where people tell us things they wouldn't say in the average conversation. And they tell us things because they understand we are at that intersection - and that we don't take sides.
Recognise there are limits
Just as we must resist being wowed by powerful people, we must also recognise that there are limits to what we can do to help the powerless.
Even with civic journalism - which I have written about before
- there is a fine balance between being proactively campaigning and not stepping beyond using the power of the pen.
You may set up public meetings for ordinary people to come to and voice their concerns about their neighbourhoods or cities or a particular issue but, essentially, the civic journalist is acting as a catalyst: to let the reader set the news agenda and to bring together the disempowered and the powerful so that there can be change.
Excellent example of civic journalism
Just last week, there was an excellent example of this kind of civic journalism going on in Cape Town, borne out of a partnership between the Cape Argus
and Eyewitness News
(which is part of Abramjee's Primedia). Called the Metrorail Diaries
, reporters from the two organisations did stories and tweeted
about their experiences of commuting by train on the various lines to the city centre.
Inspired by a New York project that involved homeless people tweeting their experiences and thoughts, the campaign got both the Western Cape transport MEC and Metrorail regional manager to commit to fixing
the problems that plague the aging fleet of commuter trains, such as delays and security.
It remains to be seen if these promises will be pursued and I think the Argus
could have injected a bit more pizazz into its campaign - this being a critical part of readers' lives and the future plans of the city. But it was informative, proactive journalism that tackled a hugely important part of Capetonian life and it leaves a crucial legacy - the Metrorail Diaries Twitter handle
on Twitter - that could well end up being a galvanising point as it has been picked up and is being used by commuters to report problems on the train lines.
We need more of this
Long may this conversation on this hashtag last - and well done to the Argus
and Eyewitness News for starting the conversation. We need more of this kind of campaigning journalism - and less of Abramjee's petitions.
It makes me proud to read my Argus
when I'm on the train.