Submit newsAdvertise & rates  23°C Johannesburg Contact us
Press offices

Marketing & Media news

Common creativity at work

8 Sep 2008 08:222 commentsBizLike
A recent comment by a friend about the music industry's reluctance to publish and distribute music under Creative Commons licence because it can't exactly give the music away free, may not be entirely unexpected, but it does bother me somewhat because his comment typifies a perception of Creative Commons that is both inaccurate and hampers adoption of Creative Commons licences in the commercial world.
I'll pause for a moment and explain what I just wrote because you may not be too familiar with some of the terminology I just threw at you.

For starters, there is an organisation called Creative Commons (http://creativecommons.org) which formulated a set of content licences referred to as Creative Commons licenses. There are six core Creative Commons licences. It isn't necessary to discuss the distinctions between these licences for the purposes of this article but I am happy to take you through if you would like me to (give me a shout, we'll do coffee). What is important to know is that these licences operate in the context of copyright law so they are not alternatives to copyright itself but rather tools that rely on copyright for their efficacy. The reason that this is important to know lies in the nature of copyright.

Form of protection

Copyright is a form of protection that was formulated to encourage innovation and creativity by protecting creators' rights to the works they created (in legalese, the creators are known as "Authors" and the stuff they create is known as "Works") and which ensures that their works may only be used in an authorised manner by people authorised by the creator to do so. Copyright protects forms of expression that may include written works (copyright vests in this article, as well as in the doodles on your note pad), sound recordings, sheet music and videos, to name just a few types of works.

To put it another way, copyright is a bundle of rights in works which vest in the authors of the works and which are intended to protect works by limiting who can exploit those rights to the works. These rights include the right to make copies, create adaptations of the original works, sell the works and publish those works.

Essentially, once you reduce your ideas to a tangible form, you generally enjoy protection through copyright. As a creator, you are more likely to create more stuff if your ability to exploit your creations is protected and you are able to guard against any form of unauthorised use of your creations - certainly uses that run contrary to your intended use of your creations.

While it may have been conceived to stimulate creativity, the use of copyright has changed over time to effectively become a bar to creativity and innovation because copyright holders have elected to rather use copyright to lock down their works, preventing the exploitation of those works - except in terms of licences they grant. These licences permit other people to make use of the works by granting them limited rights to the works concerned.

Misapprehension

Take a music CD as an example. Many people labour under the misapprehension that when they buy a CD from a music store, they become the "owner" of that CD and can do with it as they wish. If you take a look at the tiny print at the back of the CD on your shelf, you will notice that when you bought the CD you actually licensed the CD from the nebulous "music company" and you have very limited rights to the music which do not include the right to make copies of the music (whether onto another CD or by ripping the CD to your computer) or pass the music around.

You can pretty much listen to the CD and appreciate the fine album art in the company of your personal CD-playing devices. You can't play the music in public or make a remix of your favourite tune and share it online. If you do anything outside the very limited parameters of the licence granted to you when you handed over your hard-earned cash to the cashier, you are committing copyright infringement.

Set the parameters

That is what licences do; they set the parameters of your use of the content they are created for, and any use outside the parameters of the license is unauthorised and constitutes copyright infringement.

In the second part of this three-part series, I will explore some of the options available to someone who may want to make use of content protected by copyright. I also write about Creative Commons licences and what they are.

Published under a Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 2.5 ZA licence.
 
More options

About Paul Jacobson

Paul Jacobson (http://paul.myplaxo.com) is a new media lawyer working in Johannesburg with a general commercial legal practice, Jacobson Attorneys (http://jacobson.co.za/about. He is currently a member of the Advisory Council on The Open Knowledge Definition Project, Sub-Committee 71L (document description and processing languages) and is the legal advisor to a number of non- profit organisations. Paul speaks at universities and conferences globally about new media and the law and writes about these issues (and others) on his blog http://pauljacobson.org. Follow him on Twitter at http://twitter.com/pauljacobson.View MyBiz profile and articles...
Alwyn
warm bodies attending performances is where music makes money-
Seems to me Boo!'s experience in Europe in the 90s proved that owning copy right to music delivers only a trickle of revenue for the artists.
Hosting the gig, or getting a stake of the gate-takings, is where the REAL income gets made.
Hence there is a new groundswell among serious musicians to treat "illegally" toasted copies of their music, and even mpgs on You Tube, as a very cheap way to first advertise themselves and then attract customers to their next perfomance.
Of course, this "toast'em brigade" has to go out and meet their customers by touring constantly, which demand they must actually be able to play live and unplugged.

Alwyn Posted on 9 Sep 2008 08:54
Unathi
first sale doctrine-
I've read some of the clauses on the back of these CDs and DVDs - must say they're quite an optimistic lot. Based on the first sale doctrine of 'I will do as I please after forking out my cash for it!' I'd say to hell with their licensing conditions - it's mine - how and with whom I use it is none of their business. Now apply their silly rules across other media such as magazines (which I have yet to see copyright clauses on) - heck even apply this to general appliances such as fridges, stoves, etc and I'm sure the banality of copyright holders' requests starts shining through. You can't go around monitoring what Jack and Jill are up to with their purchases - the best thing would be to follow Alwyn's (previous commentator) methodolgy: forget the sale of the tangible good and rather focus efforts in concerts,brand-related merchandising, talks, buy-my-CD-and-I'll-autograph-it events, and many more...

As for the neo-liberalist agenda-driven Creative Commons hullabaloo - it's far to idealist in my view and no world can work like that - think money, money, money... Posted on 9 Sep 2008 14:40
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. defamation, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.

Subscribe to industry newsletters


Bizcommunity has over 400 industry contributors and we always welcome further contributions and contributors.

Subscribe

Receive free email newsletter

Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phoneFollow us

Invite

Tell a friend about us