Subscribe

free to biz newsletters

Bizcommunity.com - Daily Marketing & Media news
Printing forums

Unscrupulous small print publishers

7 Sep 2005 14:437 commentsBizLike
I've recently observed that some small to medium sized publishers in this country have a unique practice.
These unscrupulous business owners draw huge salaries from the business to the point of bankcruptcy, declare the business insolvent to avoid paying debt, and promptly continue business under a new operating name and new figurehead but continue to draw funds as a shareholder!

Often, the only 'circulation' they have is to the advertisers who placed material in their magazines and a few hand-outs at exhibitions, a few mailed out and a few 'dumped' at a company or government office!

What is not known, however, is that although they seem to shut business, they re-appear under a different guise again almost immediately. Not traceable by law, I'm sure.

And its not only the complete 'unknowns' that do this - some have been operating like this for many years, particularly in the trade and b2b environment, where they are not high profile enough to be fully audited, and even if they are, there appears to be some kind of 'overlooking' of the facts.

Not all small publishers are dishonest. Ask the right questions and don't just assume that a claimed ABC audit is enough. Find out who amongst the target audience has heard of or read the magazines, how long they have been trading under the same name, and even in that case, if all of their titles are legitimate just because one or two of them are. This is often a smoke-screen for the company to launch many more that don't have the same credentials.
 
More options
< Back 
Observations
A PICA award doesn't make it legitimate either-
Just because a magazine has won an award, doesn't make it immune from this practise. Either the award committee assumes the honesty of the company based on a few stamps like "member of the publishers association" or the people in the committee are aware of the practises themselves (not likely, but a possibility). Either way, there is a great deal of covering up happening in the publishing industry and its up to the advertisers and marketers to be careful and knowledgeable about where they spend their money. Ask the readers directly, not the publishers, for feedback on the efficacy of the publication, or if they have even read it. Sadly, ABC circulation stamps are not the guarantee they once were. Posted on 8 Sep 2005 15:14
Ethics have nothing to do with the size of the business!!!-
There are numerous people with decent values who have left some of the BIGGER/BIGGEST publishers because of lies about circulations. And not only B2B! One major publisher cut cirulcations at least one title without informing advertisers. Why? The profit contribution wasn't good enough! Cut print, cut mailing .... Ethics and lack thereof have nothing to do with the size of the company! In fact, the bigger companies can get away with it for longer! Posted on 8 Sep 2005 16:42
Always learning
Good point-
That's interesting, and a good point.
Business and ethics in general would appear to need a wake up! Since we can't make other people honest, the onus is on us to ask the right questions and not support employers by keeping quiet about it when we discover it. Posted on 8 Sep 2005 17:25
Ma Baker
In defense of the small B2B business-
Some small to medium enterprises have more scruples and are more honest than most of the bigger publishers.

If people are willing to accept all at face value and advertise in any Joe Soap's mag... good if they are taken for a ride.

A professional and well run smaller publication sometimes have a 100% success rate, and can offer the client references to prove it.

Please do not now classify them all in the same group. Posted on 9 Sep 2005 08:29
And, their pay stinks -
i would like to add that altho these small time knock and drops make a killing with advertising and staff sometimes have to work around the clock the pay stinks big time. working at community newspapers or any newspaper other than Independent is a big NO for journos. Stick to the big newspapers because they, altho having their own hiccups, pay their staff accordingly and there is more scope. those who advertise in these papers obviously don't worry about quality reporting as long as the money is good for the owner things are gr8.
a big up for newspapers that provide accurate and factual reporting. Posted on 12 Sep 2005 08:03
Hilary
You should know what the corporate publishers get up to!-
Ja, having been in publishing for about 18 years, it is SOOO frustrating how little attention clients pay to the value offering. I KNOW competitors are lying about their circulation, dishing up appalling content and production values, engaging in dodgy practices etc. but as long as the skirt's short enough and the sales pitch slick enough the clients just don't do the very simple homework. Frankly as a publisher if you're offering a great product you're at a disadvantage - rationality doesn't come into it Posted on 10 Feb 2006 09:51
Fine Point-
You make a good point here. I am always looking around learning new things. Thanks


www.A-Plus-Printing.com Posted on 31 Mar 2006 21:23
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.

Community activity

  • Marcel Rossouw Owner at Molasses created a profile
    1 hours, 26 minutes ago
  • Nhlanhla Brian Mdima teacher created a profile
    1 hours, 27 minutes ago
  • Samukelo Mahlalela Sound Engineer, Composer, Jingle writer created a profile
    1 hours, 33 minutes ago
  • lillian mohale HARD WORKING STUDENA AT THE UNIVERSITY OF LIMPOPO created a profile
    2 hours, 51 minutes ago
  • Dane Torode Dane Torode Multimedia Design & Illustration created a profile
    3 hours, 1 minutes ago
  • Sandy Mays Owner and founder of Blue Juice Design graphic design and communications agency created a profile
    3 hours, 10 minutes ago
  • Courtenay Carey Marketing and Brand Manager at Thiela Image created a profile
    4 hours, 5 minutes ago
  • Allana Widdison Event Management at Oakfield Farm created a profile
    4 hours, 7 minutes ago
  • sacha weber French Art Director&Supervisor, Illustrator&Designer created a profile
    4 hours, 16 minutes ago
  • Leon Marais Customs Expert at N.C. International Trade Corp. created a profile
    4 hours, 38 minutes ago
  • maxon gwijane Hotel Manager at Sun International created a profile
    4 hours, 40 minutes ago
  • Shaun Brickell Managing Director at Umlilo created a profile
    5 hours, 7 minutes ago
  • Thatelo Mahlatsi Student Assistant at University of the Free State created a profile
    5 hours, 16 minutes ago
  • Yarnall Rick Project Manager at FitSost created a profile
    5 hours, 43 minutes ago
  • titleseo service TitleSEO.Com created a profile
    5 hours, 50 minutes ago
  • Peter Veazey Air Ambulance and Air Ambulance repatriation at Air Ambulance Internationa created a profile
    6 hours, 8 minutes ago
  • karabo Phosa Intern Communications at Iphulomedia created a profile
    6 hours, 29 minutes ago
  • Cheryl Berger Executive Personal Assistant created a profile
    7 hours, 5 minutes ago
  • k p Mac Technician at B + B Sandton Garden Stay Over created a profile
    7 hours, 28 minutes ago
  • Deon van der Westhuizen created a profile
    7 hours, 45 minutes ago
  • Michael Cronje Sales executive,medical consultant at D6 Ad Sales created a profile
    8 hours, 25 minutes ago
  • Samantha du Plessis Kids Creations Art Studio created a profile
    8 hours, 28 minutes ago
  • Suzann Prinsloo Marketing and Digital Consultant created a profile
    9 hours, 30 minutes ago
  • Gwynne Searle General Manager at Phat Pak cc created a profile
    9 hours, 48 minutes ago
  • Kareema Jamie Media Strategist at Nota Bene created a profile
    10 hours, 28 minutes ago
Follow us:


Subscribe

Receive free email newsletter

Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phone

Invite

Tell a friend about us