Thieve, another product of the Bellville “rock city” generation, recently launched their debut album, GOLD. Unfortunately, while this northern suburb of Cape Town has produced successful musicians in the form of Fokofpolisisekar, Van Coke Kartel, New Holland, aKING, Die Heuwels Fantasties, Foto Na Dans, Jax Panik and Ashtray Electric, who have all made quite a name for themselves on the South African rock scene, Thieve doesn't quite meet the grade.
But this isn't for lack of effort or enthusiasm - they have these important ingredients needed to succeed. Putting it bluntly, they are bland. There's nothing about Thieve - be it stage presence or sound - that makes them stand out. While some of their Bellville brothers came out in support of the launch it was notable, while scanning the crowd during the set, that no one was feeling the music. Music in this genre is supposed to touch you deep in your soul and will you to move your body; Thieve failed in this instance to inspire much more than a forced bopping of random heads.
I could complain about the lack of promised free tequila (or perhaps it was served after the performance), or the late start that was supposed to be at 8pm and turned into 9.45pm. I could even whine about the lack of professionalism during the launch - band members should not be socialising and frolicking amongst the guests if their instruments are not tuned and the sound has not been completely sorted out - being nervous for an album launch is no excuse. While these hiccups did leave a bad taste in my mouth, it was the music itself that was too indistinct to leave much of an impression on me or the rest of the crowd.
Thieve is made up of Andrew Davenport on vocals and bass (formerly of Ashtray Electric), Fred Den Hartog, on guitar and backing vocals (formerly of Die Helde) and Philip Erasmus on the drums (formerly of New Loud Rockets). While the threesome does try to produce enjoyable music, Davenport's vocals are just not strong or distinct enough. Their one redeeming grace is in the form of Den Hartog, who has the potential to be a great guitarist. Disappointed with the launch performance, I listened to the album - different medium, same result - the songs are just not catchy enough.
Thieve are signed to indie label Supra Familias and recorded GOLD at B Sharp Studios. The one track with great potential, Last Day December, has a vibey African backbeat, but I'm afraid Thieve are going to need a whole lot more of everything to make it big on SA rock turf, because the competition nowadays is tough and it seems the Bellville wave of success can no longer be ridden.
I don't, at this point in time, see any real potential for this band, but go on Thieve, prove me wrong.
For more on Thieve, view their profile on Myspace or on Facebook.
Sindy Peters (@sindylp) is the Head of New Content Development at Bizcommunity.com and content manager and contributor on the BizLifestyle section. She can be reached at .
I totally disagree with you. Thieve's music is awesome and very catchy. It'll be interesting to see what the rest of South Africa thinks - especially now that its first track has been playlisted on 5fm. I personally think they're much better than Van Coke Kartel and Ashtray Electric... two bands I'm quite surprised have even managed to establish a following as their music is 'bland'. Listen to Thieve - especially Last Day December - and you'll soon catch on to the chorus. If not, you're as soul-less as a stone. Posted on 11 Nov 2009 12:44
Sindy, you should get fired. You obviously graduated last year and know nothing about live music or people, because your getting ripped off big time by live music lovers.
Maybe you should go work for Die Son. Becasue you just don't fit in as a reporter of anything cool especially music.
What is it about some of the people posting comments? Is it not sufficient to simply disagree - or is it absolutely essential in your view to personally attack the character and qualities of anyone who holds a view that differs from yours? Do you do the same face to face... in your family, in your job? Posted on 8 Jan 2010 06:46
Anyone with an ounce of music appreciation will love Thieve. Maybe the ''reporter'' ( if you like to called her that) just had a bad night. Instead of shutting her pie hole and listening, she was winning about free tequila and the band members interacting with the crowd and having a fat conversation while the band was playing and spoiling it for everyone else around her.
And when she notice everyone else enjoyed the music, and that she was the only miserable person in Cape Town at that moment - she could not stand it, and she had to leave.
Next time you should go and watch an Orchestra. You clearly don't fit in with the Cape Town music scene. Posted on 8 Jan 2010 09:17
Thats exactly the problem. You can't compare every new band with all bands from Bellville, that would just be stereotyping. Instead accept that Theive is not of the same type of band that would usually come out of Bellville, so let's stop stagnating on the fact that everything coming from Bellville has to sound like aKing etc. It's a testament even from this bad review and the comments it triggered, that Thieve is by all measures a excellent band as most people who commented disagreed with the review. In short, if you don't like Thieve, then don't go to the gig and then complain about it afterwards. I would not go to a death metal gig, and then say it was shyte! Posted on 12 Jan 2010 10:58
Another great band from Bellville Rock City, climbs out of the woodwork. Thieve is going to steal the hearts of South African Music lovers. A four-piece band based in and around Cape Town. They describe their sound as an unashamed combination of elements from varied popular genres, however still consider themselves as a Rock ‘n Roll act.
The band consists which consists of Andrew Davenport (Vocals and Rhythm guitar); Fred Den Hartog (Lead guitar); Jako Swanepoel (Bass Guitar) and Philip Erasmus (Drums) are due to embark on their latest journey in April, which consists of the boys traveling up to B' Sharp Studios in Boksburg, and taking on the task of recording their first full-length offering, due for release May 2009.
Album Launch Dates are as follows - 8 May: Chevelle, Cape Town; 27 May: Back 2 Basix, Johannesburg; 29 May: The Woods, New town, Johannesburg; 30 May: Firkin, Centurion; 2 June: Tings n Times, Pretoria and 3 June Tings n Times, Pretoria. Posted on 13 Jan 2010 15:35
I must agree with this write up. Thieve is purely boring. Thats all, over hyped. Seen them live twice. Average band that has this "i need to like them because they are in the Bellville scene" Posted on 4 Jul 2010 11:44
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.