Submit newsAdvertise & rates  23°C Johannesburg Contact us
Design forums

What is it with some agencies that require people that are all rounders?

29 Sep 2005 14:2810 commentsBizLike
It is a bit like going to your general practitioner (Doc) to get a spine fusion done or your eyes fixed, that is what the specialists are there for. The design agency should work the same way, because when you employ general people you get general work but if you employ a specialist you get exceptional work.
Also with a specialist there is a good chance that they know the workings of the general stuff. Not to mention this but there is a big difference in cost between a general practitioner and a specialist.

I talk for myself as I am a digital person that has no interest in print. Yes I understand how print works plus I know how to use Photoshop and Freehand as I have also lectured in the print field but I decided to specialize in the digital arena as this is where my strength lies. I use fireworks and Dreamweaver to design and implement websites, Fireworks is also good for the interface design for multimedia projects. To put the interactive project together you can use Director or Flash with a heap of other programs to do all sorts of other stuff like music, video etc. Multimedia design is not flat design process either as there is a lot of timeline thinking (another word for lateral thinking) that goes into a project, for example how do you want the button to react when it is clicked plus where does it need to go. Designing for a website, multimedia and print are very different processes yes it can be one design but that will fail and the project ends up not looking very professional as digital and print have very different rules for design and layout.

I know I go on about this but when you lay people thin by having them as an all rounder what you get is very thin work. A person that is employed because they have a strong point and understanding of what they do and they are passionate about the work they do you get a solid foundation to build the most amazing things. Projects also take time and for most agencies time is money so you waste time by having one person doing 3 designs and then creating a print job, the website and maybe the multimedia. A digital person required to do print work is like starting form scratch because you don’t use the programs often it takes you a lot longer to set up your work environment and getting the elements together.

It is not a good practice that people should waste their degrees, diplomas, years of training and experience sitting with the wrong work on there plates. Not only do these people’s creative juices start drying up but the work becomes less then perfect. Let’s practice putting people in the right places and watch you business sore because happy creative people are a force to be reckoned with.
 
More options
    Kams
    I agree-
    A designer needs to a jack of all trades and a master of none - it seems that's the way the situation is. It's daunting to prospective candidates as companies make one feel under qualified to do the job. I'd rather be a master of one medium as it's my strenght, than to be all over the place and feel as if I have under-achieved on many projects. Posted on 3 Oct 2005 09:22
    thembi
    multi skilled-
    What about being multi skilled and still specialize in one particular skill. Posted on 3 Oct 2005 12:41
    Lantz
    Great-
    Very cool plan, it has served me well, but don't forget to keep your main skill sharp because in the computer design world things happen fast. Posted on 3 Oct 2005 15:27
    Designer-4-sale
    Take a breath...-
    Look, to understand the management of a company, one must become the management of a company. Let's put it this way, if I owned my own design studio for instance, I too would want to employ an all-rounder...it means I have to fork out less for you to keep me happy. Simple! Should I start employing specialists in print, web, interactive, 3d and all that good stuff...my company would run at a loss just from paying salaries. Welcome to the real world...it's so cruel! Posted on 11 Oct 2005 22:47
    Mark Rowlands
    Depends what you're looking for...-
    Whilst I agree that the quality of the work output from a 'specialist' would be higher if it was in his/her speciality field, there is also the problem of being so specialised that you don't have that many opportunities to use that knowledge. It is far better to have a grounding in overall design from conception thru' design to print so as to have the maximum exposure to possible work opportunities. You could end up being specialised in sitting around doing nothing! lol
    I cut my teeth as a junior copy-writer in a (now defunct) ad agency in the early 80's, from there I moved up to lay-out artist, PMT machine operator, etc. learning all the way.
    I eventually found out that my forte lay in conceptual design and in 2D rendering and design of 3D product packaging. What I'm trying to say is that before computer-based desing courses we had to draw camera-ready artwork by hand, and be available to help out where we were needed and we were trained to be able to do just that - was the work output "thin" - I don't know, just how many Jumbo Golf II's were sold in the Eastern Cape(that was one of our accounts)? I suppose some areas need certain levels of expertise and, if you can crack the nod, you will eventually be head-hunted for what you can do by somebody that needs that specific talent. I love the whole process from talking to the client to getting the finished job back from the print-shop. Posted on 3 Oct 2005 13:43
    Sophia Dower
    Be a specialist-generalist-
    As a copywriter, I consider myself a specialist. However, without a general understanding of the related print, electronic and marketing areas in which my copy is used, I would not be able to produce content that sends the right message to the right person in the right way.

    Additionally, being able to write insightful copy depends on an indepth understanding of my clients' businesses and their roles in the SA economy. I guess that makes me a writer who knows "a lot about a little" - a specialist generalist, perhaps?

    I think any specialist is a generalist who's capitalised on their strong points. And who would want to hire anything else? Posted on 4 Oct 2005 09:55
    rosem
    It depends-
    Being an all rounder depends on ones level of skills.If a person is at Junior level,to be an all rounder becomes more beneficial to them to acquire more skills, because at that stage a person cant pin point their strengths. At a long run they know what they are good at and start putting more effort and follow that root. That is when they become specialist.
    Its like at high school , your first year you are taught almost all subject and as you move standards you get to know which subjects you master and follow them. Posted on 25 Oct 2005 08:12
    Bandit
    All rounders-
    I do agree with you to a certain extent. In order to get the best creative results one should specialize in one or two things. However, the design industry is growing so fast and everchanging software (some better - some worse) that its not really feasible to be single minded about these things.
    I also believe that by making yourself or becoming an all-rounder makes you more "employable". Who out there has lately been looking for work? It is not easy anymore, even with proper qualifications and experience. The compitition is always stiff and literally hundreds of people apply for the exact same position. Thus by making yourself more employable, you stand a much better chance.
    Besides, the more you know and the more you are capable of the better. One should always try to improve on yourself and your situation. Become an expert in more than one area.
    Unlike a race-horse you are not forced to look in one direction only. You are doing it to yourself.
    I am a computer graphic artist by trade, not only do I do print design, but also digital design, general office admin, sales, purchasing, marketing, video editing, etc etc etc... I push al my effort and concentration on the job at hand. This makes me successful in everything I do. Posted on 6 Dec 2005 11:38
    Ilse
    I agree-
    I agree Posted on 20 Jun 2006 16:55
    PhibaOptik
    i'm even more cheesed off at agencies loking to employ entry level personnel WITH agency experience-
    i have been knocking at almost every agency and web design company's door since transmigrating from (top salary paying) Cape Town to Durban.. had to eventually settle for a job in customer service with a cellular network.

    have since started working from home, and the work just comes.. God knows where from.. this since i let out that I CAN design..

    Now even the customer service division of teh cellular network is bypassing their agency and i get commissions to do work for them...

    some agency's loss... Posted on 12 Aug 2006 22:19
    LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. defamation, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.

    Subscribe to industry newsletters


    Subscribe

    Receive free email newsletter

    Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phoneFollow us

    Invite

    Tell a friend about us