Renting out your property? Avoid these common landlord mistakes

Source: Supplied. Regard Budler, chief executive officer of BetterSure Financial Consultants.

Landlords must navigate legal obligations, tenant disputes, property maintenance, insurance considerations and unexpected events that can threaten their investment.

Understanding where lease agreements apply, when insurance offers protection, and how to manage risks proactively can help landlords avoid costly mistakes while safeguarding both their property and their rental income.

Legal first steps

Your lease agreement is your first line of defence: One of the biggest mistakes landlords make is assuming that every disagreement with a tenant is an insurance matter. In reality, most disputes are contractual issues governed by the lease agreement and the Rental Housing Act.

Problems such as excessive noise, unauthorised occupants, prohibited pets or repeated breaches of body-corporate rules should generally be addressed through the terms of the lease. Landlords should first attempt to resolve the matter directly with the tenant. If this isn't successful, the relevant provincial Rental Housing Tribunal offers an accessible alternative to court, helping mediate disputes and determine whether either party has failed to meet their obligations.

While these types of disputes don't usually trigger an insurance claim, they shouldn't be ignored. Left unresolved, relatively minor issues can escalate into costly legal disputes, property damage, or financial losses.

"The legal process and your insurance policy each have a distinct role to play," says Regard Budler, chief executive officer of BetterSure Financial Consultants. "Understanding the difference helps landlords respond appropriately while protecting both their property and their investment."

Screen tenants carefully

Good property management goes a long way: Successful landlords know that protecting a rental property starts long before anything goes wrong. Careful tenant screening, a well-drafted lease agreement, and thorough incoming and outgoing inspections can prevent many disputes before they arise.

Keeping dated photographs, signed inspection reports, and maintenance records can prove invaluable if disagreements occur or damage needs to be assessed. Routine inspections during the lease period are equally important, allowing landlords to identify problems such as leaking roofs, burst pipes, damp, mould or unauthorised alterations before they become expensive repairs.

Landlords also have an ongoing responsibility to maintain their property. Ignoring known maintenance issues can not only increase repair costs but may also complicate legal disputes or insurance claims if the damage worsens over time.

Residential Property

Why this lease choice matters for landlords and long-term property performance

9 Jul 2026

One of the biggest misconceptions among landlords is that insurance automatically covers every type of tenant-related damage. In reality, cover depends on the circumstances, the policy wording, and the type of damage. Accidental damage may be covered, while malicious damage is often subject to specific conditions or optional extensions. Regardless of whether insurance responds, tenants remain legally responsible for damage they cause, and landlords may pursue recovery of repair costs where appropriate.

Know your responsibilities

When circumstances change, your responsibilities change too: Many homeowners notify neither their insurer nor their broker when the way a property is used changes. Whether converting a family home into shared accommodation, renting out multiple rooms or listing the property on short-term rental platforms such as Airbnb, different occupancy arrangements create different risks and may require different insurance considerations.

Illegal activity presents another challenge altogether. If a landlord becomes aware that a property is being used for unlawful purposes, it's important to seek legal advice, notify the relevant authorities where necessary, and follow the correct legal process. Criminal activity can expose the property to damage, police investigations, and significant financial consequences. While every insurance claim is assessed on its own merits, losses linked to unlawful use may not always be covered.

Another situation that often causes uncertainty is the death of a landlord. Many tenants assume the lease automatically comes to an end, but this is generally not the case. The lease usually continues, with the deceased estate assuming the landlord's rights and obligations until ownership is transferred. During this period, tenants must continue complying with the lease, while the appointed executor manages the property and ensures it remains appropriately protected.

Rental properties can provide stable, long-term returns, but protecting that investment requires more than simply collecting rent. Understanding your legal obligations, maintaining your property, keeping accurate records, and knowing when insurance can help enables landlords to respond confidently when challenges arise.

A proactive approach, supported by a strong lease agreement, good property management, and appropriate insurance cover, remains the best way to protect one of your most valuable assets.