Sites: Africa, Marketing, Medical, Retail
Marketing community of South Africa
Marketing> The Loerie Awards 2008, Advertising, Branding, Cinema, CRM, Design, Digital, Direct Marketing, Education & Training, Eventing, Exhibitions, Magazines, Media, Mobile, Newspapers, Online Media, Out Of Home, Printing, Production, Promotions, Public Relations, Radio, Recruitment, Research, Retail, Sales, Sponsorship, TV, Youth Marketing, 2010 FIFA World Cup
Africa> Southern Africa, South Africa
Comments

Comments on Sowetan Freedom Day ad: parody or reality check?
 
Sowetan Freedom Day a reality check  by  Ziggy
I believe so much in Freedom of Speech, I truly commend the Sowetan Editor for publishing their ad unlike other companies who chicken out. As a nation we need to look back,and do some introspection pertaining to what "Freedom" really means in South Africa.Does it mean having to watch my back while driving on the road,or worrying when my husband is late,or having to buy a 90 million wall to protect me and my loved ones or having to worry about being raped,or having to worry about my kid if he/she is safe,having to buy alarms and pay exorbitant insurances in my automobile? Wake up South Africa it's about time something gets done!
3 May 2007 10:40   Reply, Report this comment
Let it be heard ....  by  A. Ray
The ANC's government TV station (SABC-TV) could never have flighted that advert.
It would have been a slap in their own face with the reality and truth.

In short, it would amount to political suicide and had they allowed it to run it would have been a serious clm for the individuals that allowed it and there would have been some major 'smacks-on-the-wrists' at the broadcaster.

It is a pity it was not allowed to run on the state broadcaster - as more people would have been exposed to the everyday realities. Those officials huddled behind, secured, walled, fenced, patrolled and gated areas, might also have come to realise that there is a problem.

Unlike them, we travel at normal speeds, not under escorted patrols & not in convoys, skipping traffic lights etc. We have to stop at a highway offramp, that has a warning that it is a Hi-jack hotspot.

Let the message be heard, maybe someone will actually react
3 May 2007 11:36   Reply, Report this comment
Its about time  by  Comrade
Thank you Sowetan for bringing the reality of our nation to light. Yes we have freedom, but are we really free when we constantly fear for for our kids, our lives? It is about time South Africa wakes up and acknowledges that we do have problems in our society, severe ones in fact, it is no ones fault but our responsibility. How can you deal with something if you do not acknowledge that it does exist. This is a wake up call to government and all South African society to stand together and do something to eradicate these social evils possessing our society. We celebrate Freedom day every year year-on-year yet our own people are dying due to violent crimes, HIV/AIDS, our kids and even grannies are raped and killed. Let us all stand together to reinstore the moral fabric of our society. I visited the apartheid museum, there is a section hailing the Freedom Era of post '94 yet even the displays show pictures of our people living in shacks with no water, sanitation, hungry children who cannot go to school, yet we hail Freedom??? Please!!!! Freedom is not about the BEE elite driving their Bentley's living in the Dainferns of this city, protected by boom gates and on site security guards...oh yes, these are the few free people that can honestly celebrate Freedom Day...But what about me, what about you, what about my brothers and sisters, my granny and grandpa...by the millions living in constant fear for their their lives, living with the anxiety of not having enough to eat, being disempowered by not having education, not having proper health care, being forced to desperate means of living at the risk of contracting deadly diseases, I am talking about these people, that South Africa...is still ignoring in this Freedom Era. Can they honestly celabrate Freedom in their Time??????
3 May 2007 14:44   Reply, Report this comment
Reality check  by  Laqash
Our Nation and especially South Africa's political elite needs a wake up call of "megaton" proportions, about the reality of what's happening in South Africa today. And this is one but a small start.
3 May 2007 16:49   Reply, Report this comment
What is freedom....  by  TIM SINGISWA
The SABC was right on principle and conscience not to air that ad since it misses the point as to the kind of freedom South Africans yearned for.

Even if crime can be eradicated sOUTH aFRICANS WOULD STILL NOT HAVE ATTAINED THE KIND OF FREEDOM THAT SHOULD BE ASSOCIATED WITH THAT PARTICULAR DAY.tHIS WAS POLITICAL FREEDOM FROM THE YOKE OF OPPRESSION,REPRESSION AND SUPPRESSION TO WHICH IT HAS NOT YET BEEN REALISED SINCE WE STILL FEAR EACH OTHER AND DENYING EACH OTHER THEIR HUMAN BASIC RIGHTS ON SUBTLE REASONS. i HAPPENED TO BE PASSING THE CIVICS LAWNS AND i ENCOUNTERED GUARDS WITH DOGS CHASING PEOPLE AWAY FROM THOSE LAWS ARGUING THAT THAT WAS PRIVATE PROPERTY AND i HEARD THE VICTIMS DECRYING THE FACT THAT THEY ARE STILL LEAVING UNDER APARTHEID.

tHE sOWETAN IS A VERY OBTUSE AND FOOLHARDY PAPER AND i AM NOT SURPRISED THAT THEY ONLY WENT FOR THE MONEY AND NOT CARED A HOOT AS TO IF THIS AD IS COMPATIBLE OR NOT.tHEIR READERS HAVE BEEN CRIPPLED BY ADS PUBLISHED BY THIS PAPER AND SO ITS DECISION WAS ONE OF PARATISM AND GREED.
5 May 2007 10:07   Reply, Report this comment
 
You cannot separate political freedom from social freedom  by  Kate
Yes we all know what freedom day is about and we all celebrate the freedom from apartheid rule that it represents. But don't you have to ask "freedom to do what?" What's the point of shrugging off racial oppression if we replace this with oppression of other sorts - be it gender based, abuse of our kids, oppression of greed, oppression of economic inequality driving crime, oppression from a society becoming aclimatised to violence as a means of getting what you what, any oppression of others, etc etc etc?
7 May 2007 18:12   Reply, Report this comment
Print and sound don't deliver equally  by  Commentator
Copywriters often fail to realise that what is appropriate on a page may not be when delivered by other media; the message is received quite differently aurally to visually. The eye can return and reread, the mind check and redefine what is seen. But the mind frequently apprehends only partially what it hears, especially when it comes from a source on which one is not concentrating, like a radio commercial. The irony is lost in words that are heard and are likely to be comprehended as exhortation. Thus the reversal of meaning is not noticed, as it is by a reader, and this message becomes something close to hate speech. The same message delivered live, where the audience sees the manner of delivery as well as hears the vocal tone, is usually clear - Pieter Dirk Uys playing the Nationalist politician is an example of this.
5 May 2007 12:08   Reply, Report this comment
Stop & think for a minute? God forbid!  by  Kate
I was horrified the first time I heard the ad, and actually thought it was going to be a whiney protest from the DA - what a surprise when I discovered it was the Sowetan! It made me think about all sorts of assumptions we make, and also how much we take for granted.
Ten thumbs up to the Sowetan for having the guts to say some uncomfortable things. Everything they mentioned has happened more than once in our country and been reported in the news time and time again. The fact is we have a fabulous country with fabulous opportunities, and do we really want to screw it up by ignoring the problems we have to sort out? Have we really used our freedom as best we could?
7 May 2007 18:04   Reply, Report this comment






LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.
 











Receive free email newsletter
 
Tell a friend about us
 
CONTACT US | ABOUT US | SEND US NEWS | ADVERTISING RATES | sales@bizcommunity.com | +27 (0)21 680 3500
All rights reserved. © 2008. Bizcommunity.com, its sponsors, contributors and advertisers disclaim all liability for any loss, damage, injury or expense that might arise from the use of, or reliance upon, the services contained herein. Privacy policy, Terms of Use.
Connected by: Uninet