Timmerity with Andrew Timm

TV, comedy and coping with life and trying to work in broadcast TV in 2010 as a white male.

Andrew Timm's dad wanted him to be an accountant. His mom wanted him to be happy. Mom won. So Andrew started out in the corporate video and today spends half his time producing corporate videos and live corporate shows, and the other half doing broadcast television (magazine shows, dramas, and now The Coconuts sitcom for M-Net). Contact Andrew at and find out more about his company at www.attv.co.za.

Why international TV drama is better

31 Aug 2010 12:08:00

Anyone who has spent more than five minutes in South Africa knows that this country has great stories to tell. And I'm not talking about rehashed apartheid guilt stuff. Just open a newspaper on any given day, listen to a conversation in a taxi, or to the callers on 702, and unlike New Zealand or Canada, where a flat tyre on a country road makes headline news, you will realise that we seem able to generate endless tales of human drama and intrigue.

South Africans are just interesting people!

So why, when you sit down to watch the latest local drama on any of the local TV channels, do you find yourself flicking to Desperate Housewives, Grey's Anatomy or CSI (any one of them)?

Now I know that you are thinking, he's going to say "Budget!" No, that's lower on the list, the real answer is simply this - interesting stuff happens constantly. Profound, isn't it?

Took me years to work it out

It took me years to work it out but it's as simple as that. There are no dull moments, awkward pauses or great ‘wadges' of unnecessary dialogue. Every frame is moving the story or the character development along.

Simply put, a lot of what we pass as one-hour TV drama is actually half-hour TV drama stretched out with long shots of cars arriving, people walking, and hopelessly flabby dialogue scenes.

Okay, budget does come into it, because you need great writers to make great drama, but great writers ARE writing some of our drama! But then the producer comes along and (understandably) says, "No, you can't have the earth exploding and bodies flying through space!" It's the reality of ever-dwindling TV budgets!

But that's no excuse for some of the obvious padding we have to put up with. It's often just lazy writing, self-indulgent direction and sloppy editing by button pushers who aren't real storytellers.

It's really not that our stories aren't as interesting as those on the American dramas; it's just that in many cases we aren't telling them right.

[31 Aug 2010 12:08]


 
More options
< Back 

DodgyCam
Hate to agree with a producer ... but ...-
... Mostly you've got a point.

US TV particularly is extremely densely packed.

And, if I might be so bold there IS a US series that holds the blueprint for what South African TV should and could aspire to ...

The Wire (arguably the best TV show ever made) adopted a simple and quite remarkable position.

'This' they said. 'Is a unique world, with a unique culture and language. This is a robust world different in almost every respect to any other. But we will not try to soften that, we will not try to de-code it and make it easy to understand. Because it is the very uniqueness of that world that makes it interesting. Therefore, we will try to capture the essences of that world in an uncompromising way. We will expect our audience to work hard in order to decode it. We will demand that they 'listen carefully' ... And, if they do, they will be rewarded with a real vision of a world they would never otherwise experience.'

The lesson here is simple ... Instead of trying to water down our South African stories - making them generic and easily accessible to the widest possible audience (at home and abroad) ... we should celebrate the things that make our own communities unique, and use the medium to take people into those unvarnished worlds.

The richness of the language, the diversity of attitude and opinion and opportunity - these are not things to be denied or hidden behind a false façade of Castle Larger Ad reality ... These differences are the things we should embrace and celebrate.

Our stories would be stronger for it and we would perhaps understand each other a little better if we were all asked to make the effort to 'listen carefully'

Go watch the Wire, then tell me why we have not already put a couch in the middle of some open ground and waited to see just who came to sit there and just what they had to say ...
dC Posted on 7 Sep 2010 11:29
PLR book-
yes...i totaly agree with yur comment....sir...


.........
stevjones Posted on 3 Oct 2010 23:02
Lorraine Gokul
Why international TV drama is better-
The reason for this is that everyone wants to be an actor, producer scriptwriter in South Africa, but the country really born into drama is America.they have what it takes which is now known to the world as the best actors, the best stories and producers, besides they have been doing this over decades.I have worked personally with Hollywood, Bollywood and Sorrywood (south Africa) lol. My ratings Hollywood still comes tops.despite South Africa working on apartheid they also take on roles with different genres. i have noticed local actors tend to over act or over dramatize to such extent that i want to yank them of the set. character development is of utmost importance in any role irrespective of how big or small a part is, and this is what lacks in local drama.i don't understand some of the linguistics used in local TV drama, is it for the literate or illiterate? a budget is what is accosted for a movie project, there are five stages to production, research and development, preproduction,production, post production and distribution. so the budget is always catered for before the movie is even actually started.so its not about budget that makes international TV better. it's about having a 3 dimensional character ,good plot and story line.even international movies are made with lower budgets. and if you take nightmare on elm street you will gain some understanding of it, all depends on the character and how they bring themselves to life in any role.so you are right of the bat when you say they not telling it right. they also aint doing it right. Posted on 13 Nov 2010 21:56
Nomali Cele
I will say only one thing, have you seen Generations lately? Appalling waste of airtime! Posted on 27 Sep 2011 14:52
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.

Subscribe

Receive free email newsletter

Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phone

Invite

Tell a friend about us