Subscribe

free to biz newsletters

Bizcommunity.com - Daily Marketing & Media news
Branding newsPress offices

Profile and articles

Vrot start for new PnP logo

19 Nov 2007 09:338 commentsBizLike
The revamped 40-year-old Pick n Pay brand did not go down well with most readers of Bizcommunity.com, who started debating this issue when the first blogpost with the breaking news was published as the press conference last Monday was happening. The poll drew 4038 page impressions (Fresh new look for iconic Pick n Pay brand) and 144 comments over the week. A total of 48.53% (642) votes by this morning indicate that our readers do not like the new logo, while 34.39% (455) think it is a winner, and 17.08% (226) are undecided.

New logo

Old logo
Here are some of the comments.

Looks very old school and dull
The new brand strategy is being launched... "Inspired by you." It would have been a good idea to interact with the consumers so that they at least feel that not only the products sold at PnP but the brand strategy was also inspired by us. When launching new strategies, one needs to ensure that it is relevant and true to the public, ensure that all loops are closed and everything is in synergy. Well done nonetheless, I don't foresee that this will negetively affect sales in anyway... which is most important. I must say though, the new logo is not inspiring at all. By Mimi

You can never do enough market research
The colour combination induces illness and I'm sure I've seen those colours somewhere in checkers. The identity in general is poor. "Inspired by you" has a good ring but its hard to spot when you feel ill. This identity is the product of a work done by a foreign agency most likely out of touch with the local market. The people of that agency don't have to go to PnP for the next 20 years looking at that logo, so needless to say I think they would have put more effort into Tesco if they had a shot. By Andre

So-So
I like the fact that the new logo is fresh and new - brands always need to re-invent themselves - however, I do not think the new look is memorable or very strong (the old brand had more personality)...I like the new payoff line though!

Completely disappointing!
Strange Eurocentric flavour - shows lack of understanding of the South African market. Homogenous, lacks personality and equity.....? By Anon.

"Elegant dark blue" and "warmer cherry red"?
Looks like a British bank logo. The overall typography is fine, but why change the colours? Red and black were clear and distinctive. These wishy-washy colours are not very bold or South African. I miss the apostrophe too. By Anon.

Looks cool
I think it looks good. It definitely has the look and feel of European retailers such as Sainsbury and Tesco's. The fact that the design team were based in UK might have something to do with this. Change is good regardless. By Promotis
 
More options
< Back
PhibaOptik
me loves-
i think the design is brilliant.

much smoother tyography.
wording a lot easier on the eye.
serify fonts are a lot less legible at first glance and this new font does it for me.

i also like the fact that in all their copy there is follow-through with the font usage.

the colour scheme is where they forgot they're esentially an AFRIKA-based company.

Pick 'n Pay needed to shed their apartheid era brand image a loooooooong time ago.. they SOOOO desperately need to rebrand their NO NAME line of products.. i hope this is in the pipeline..

respekt to Y&R for finally coming through with something better than product brochure after product brochure. Posted on 19 Nov 2007 14:12
The new ads are pretty good-
Well, we chirped and called the new logo crap. But the new ads are pretty good. Within a few months all the criticism will fall away as we accept the inevitable change. Proving that we are just resistant to change. Not that I am saying that the Pick n Pay change is good, but that we will get used to it Posted on 19 Nov 2007 15:42
It will take a while-
Pick 'n Pay has such a strong existing brand identity with massive awareness throughout South Africa. You have to expect that it will take time for many people to start accepting the change.

I think the logo is updated and will begin to become relevant in time as people begin to accept the new identity.

However, I saw the new ads last night and I think they lack impact and definitely do not create a strong enough awareness for their change.

But time will tell... Posted on 19 Nov 2007 16:17
Adibaby
If it aint broke don't fix it!!!-
Why mess with a perfectly good, powerful, well known logo? The new one is really cheap looking and a bit lame! Posted on 20 Nov 2007 07:21
Pic n Compare
It's just simple!!!-
Rather focus more on the customer service at your retail stores and "we" customers will then easily love and recon & brand you for the efficient service delivered. Posted on 20 Nov 2007 09:21
Craig W.
Too coporate-
It is clear to me that P&P are trying to develop a "group" identity that can transcend their core supermarket offering and apply to the different parts of their expanding business - banking, clothing etc. Beware losing focus from your core business...PnP is a retailer first and foremost in the eyes of its customers not a technology/FSP company.

The logo is washed out and one dimesional. The colours are weak and non-descript - I think it'll date very quickly. The tag line leaves me with a sense that they are "just saying that" and I wish I could share the same sentiment about the company. I think the current head of affairs at P&P is not in the same league as it's founder and is struggling to curb marketshare losses...change is good but I think the logo in blue and red would've been a whole lot better - looks like a committee decision. Posted on 20 Nov 2007 09:26
anonymous
Insult to South Africans-
The fact that Pick n Pay decided to use a non-South African agency to develop their new logo does little to endear them to South Africans - something they claim to hold so precious. There are many extremely talented, worldclass designers in this country who would have done a superb, more appropriate job. Posted on 20 Nov 2007 09:44
Prince Monareng
Pick 'n Pay Logo-
I have to say that the traditional Pick 'n Pay's Brand Identity has been the cornerstone of almost every South African's household. It’s really appalling that the decision- makers at Pick 'n Pay decided on re-branding. Change is acceptable in every organisation, but, such a change that was made by re-branding was wide of the mark. Surely, sales won't be affected as much by this, but it would have been well received by the public, had the re-branding was clean and catchy. Posted on 20 Nov 2007 10:11
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.
Follow us:

Community activity

  • Nicole naicker Writer created a profile
    33 minutes ago
  • Maria Pombo ESL Teacher at Hanlim Seoil Language School created a profile
    2 hours, 38 minutes ago
  • George Wakaria Business owner at Accoladebiz Co. Limited created a profile
    4 hours, 8 minutes ago
  • Oren Dayan Head of Marketing Division at UNIVERSITY OF THE WITWATERSRAND created a profile
    8 hours, 6 minutes ago
  • Julie Dawne Willis Administative Assistant at Lee Nailand Designs created a profile
    10 hours, 35 minutes ago
  • Makhosazana Modise Cash book Clerk at Legal Aid SA created a profile
    10 hours, 49 minutes ago
  • mosole Ramasodi Director at rea cherish created a profile
    10 hours, 59 minutes ago
  • khanyisa ngewu Business Development Manager at SMG Africa created a profile
    11 hours, 28 minutes ago
  • Eamonn Newell Director at Billington Cartmell Ltd. created a profile
    14 hours, 12 minutes ago
  • zameka faith nhose created a profile
    14 hours, 37 minutes ago
  • Lapologa Kgosiemang Quality officer at BP created a profile
    15 hours, 49 minutes ago
  • Jade Abbott Project Assistant at cellsmart created a profile
    15 hours, 53 minutes ago
  • Thuto Chilwane Telemarketer at College Campus created a profile
    16 hours, 58 minutes ago
  • Garikai Nhongo Sales Director at Afri-Tech Group created a profile
    17 hours, 40 minutes ago
  • Steven Viviers Independent Consultant created a profile
    17 hours, 51 minutes ago
  • Raeesa Jada Journalist created a profile
    17 hours, 56 minutes ago
  • Lutho LP Poswa created a profile
    18 hours, 2 minutes ago
  • ARCHIE SMITH National Sales Manager at Wicount (Group Buying) created a profile
    18 hours, 11 minutes ago
  • Emelda Khumalo Events Co-ordinator at Parc created a profile
    18 hours, 14 minutes ago
  • Matthew Baker Senior Web Developer (PHP/Flash/Jquery/Design) created a profile
    18 hours, 16 minutes ago
  • Andre de Wet Copywriter created a profile
    19 hours, 14 minutes ago
  • Bertus Schoeman Social Media and Website Content Manager at M-Net created a profile
    19 hours, 23 minutes ago
  • karabo segone call centre agent created a profile
    19 hours, 36 minutes ago
  • Nthabiseng Mhlambi ADMININSTRATOR at Boaz Consulting created a profile
    19 hours, 55 minutes ago
  • Nicole Ferger Accounts Executive at RedStar Communication created a profile
    20 hours, 1 minutes ago


Subscribe

Receive free email newsletter

Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phone

Invite

Tell a friend about us