Subscribe

free to biz newsletters

Bizcommunity.com - Daily Lifestyle news
Music newsPress offices

Profile and articles

aKING honours Herman Pretorius in "You & I"

6 Oct 2009 11:153 commentsBizLike
I was all ready to rip aKING's latest music video “You & I”, till I saw it had been dedicated to music ambassador Herman Pretorius who tragically lost his struggle with cancer on 20 August this year. Can you bad mouth a video that is in memory of someone? Somehow it just doesn't feel ethical - but here goes anyway.
I am sure many aKING fans would disagree with me judging by the aKING Facebook page, but the video for “You and I” is hardly what I would expect from one of SA's premier rock bands. Okay, so they are more mainstream than their Bellville Brothers, but still a music video that looks like it could belong to an artist like Danny K; (cue lead singing to pretty girl) has been done to death and is about as clichéd as you can get. It just doesn't seem fitting for a band that, in conjunction with producers Fly on the Wall (those talented guys who made the Fok-umentary), created the awesome “Safe as Houses” video. “You & I” in comparison, seriously lacks dimensionality and flavour in concept.

Don't get me wrong, it is beautifully shot and produced and includes some heartfelt scenes with the band looking serious in Argentinean cemeteries and strolling around monuments in the Recoletta district of Buenos Aires. But, somehow, the two different veins of the video, said Buenos Aires street strolling scenes and Laudo singing to a girl on a bed, don't seem compatible or do justice to the song or band.



However, the director has this to say about the making and concept behind the video: I really liked the idea of a nostalgic video. A feeling of mesmerisation - it should feel like "I've been here before". We thought that the beauty of Argentina would capture that, from the interiors to the Recoletta cemetery and the tango clubs.

I wanted to capture the essence of appreciating someone or something and capture that moment when you sit back and think of your life; how you get older, how you are going to change and the people and memories that keep it alive for you. Ironically, Herman Pretorius from MK lost his battle against cancer while we were over there and the song became very real for everyone on set. RIP HERMAN!


And the band had this to say: Going to another country on a whim, with a couple of your best friends, seemed like a wild idea at first, especially due to the fact that we were the ones footing the bill. In retrospect though, I wouldn't have wanted it any other way. The whole experience drew us closer together, not just as a band but as best friends.

Which is all quite understandable and sweet respectively and, I suppose, when creating a video for a more ballad-type song that deals with nostalgia one might not want to create anything too out there. But I'm still not really convinced that the original intentions were realised and if the “essence of appreciating someone or something” was really captured. I think it was those bed scenes that really turned me off, altogether far too soppy for a band like aKING.

Okay, I feel bad now, dissing a music video that was dedicated to Herman Pretorius (shame on me), so please visit www.vredefoundation.co.za the foundation that Pretorius founded for young people with cancer and show your support. And let us know what you think of the video - maybe it's really brilliant and I'm just not getting it.

 
More options
< Back

About Ruth Cooper


Ruth is the production manager at Bizcommunity, as well as a contributor to the entertainment section in the BizLounge. View profile and articles...
Damien du Toit
Not a big fan-
Of the music video... pretty much agree with your sentiment. But a huge fan of this band. Catching them at RTD this Friday, whooop! Posted on 7 Oct 2009 00:39
Jack Denials
honest reviews - never a bad thing-
thanks for having the temerity of posting an honest review. This country's musical acts desperately need more honest reviews in order to realise that not everything they do is golden and that not everything local is lekker. SA media is way too complimentary and music "journalists" in particular far too afraid of saying what they really feel about a band (especially if that band is from one of the hallowed grounds of Belville, or Pretoria), lest they invoke the ire of that band or that band's record label and gawd forbid - not be invited to the next VIP-only strip bar launch of new music video/ new album /new EP / new hairdo.
The local industry will never progress beyond striving for pale imitation so long as "music journos" are too scared of saying what is.
I saw the video and agree with the review on this site: it comes across as completely indulgent, as in; "let's go to Argentina just to shoot a music video and have the end product look like it was shot somewhere in Rugby. Why? Well, because we can! Because that is what successful bands do. A good excuse for a free holiday.." kind-of-thing. Perhaps it will help them get known in that thriving Argentian music market?
and i don't think the fact that the band thought to attach Herman's name to it either is reason enough to feel bad about rating the video for what it is.
Viva honesty in the music press. Vi-va! Posted on 13 Oct 2009 11:14
Pipernam
Hmmm...-
I like it! (The video) But then I'm not South African and don't share all the sentimental "has to be local and depict us" vibe that seems to be central to the theme of S.A. music at the moment. I'm also not particularly crazy about the band.

The video was shot with amazing cinematic display (in my opinion) and the song itself has my vote for one of the best South African songs I've ever come across - or let me rephrase that to songs by a South African act - as it doesn't sound very South African. Is that a bad thing? In terms of production I think this song is actually a win for S.A. music.

Can't local bands sound international (most of us listen primarily to overseas bands anyway) and compete on a level playing-field to gain success, while still maintaining their integrity as artists? I think they can. Many U.K. and Australian bands don't sound any different to U.S. bands... And then why not make a video of the same nature? Why not let the music speak for itself while watching the awesome Argentinian scenery?

For me this video creates just the right balance in stirring up emotion to compliment a really cool song. If nostalgia was the point, I'd say they succeeded. Posted on 15 Jul 2010 12:20
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.
Follow us:

Community activity

  • Francois Campbell Web Developer at White Wall Web created a profile
    5 days, 19 hours, 37 minutes ago
  • Siviwe Ngcingwana Managing Director at Black Knight Concierge (Pty) Ltd created a profile
    6 days, 13 hours, 14 minutes ago


Subscribe

Receive free email newsletter

Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phone

Invite

Tell a friend about us