Submit newsAdvertise & rates  18°C Johannesburg Contact us
Press offices
Recruitment news

Woolworth refutes accusations of racism, disables wall

7 Sep 2012 06:2920 comments1 BizLike
Ian Moir, Woolworths CEO says that it is "simply not true" to suggest that Woolworths follows racist recruitment practices - specifically, of not employing white people. The retailer has also disabled its Facebook wall after it became what the company terms "a platform for a well-orchestrated campaign of hate speech".
"The rumours apparently were sparked by some of our recruitment ads that designate certain posts for certain groups, and are being fuelled by an organisation that has called on its members to boycott us," he writes.

"As a Woolworths customer, we thought you'd like to hear the facts:
• Woolworths DOES employ white people. We employ women and men of all races - white, black, coloured, Indian, as well as people with disabilities, and will continue to do so.
• We're a passionately South African company, so diversity is important to us. So is offering fair career opportunities. There are some areas of our business where certain groups are seriously under represented. These are the positions where we actively look for qualified candidates from specific groups.
• Most other businesses do the same to bring diversity into their workforces. In fact, in South Africa all businesses that have more than 50 employees are required to do this.
• We believe the responsible thing to do is to be open and transparent in our recruitment ads about the type of candidates we are looking for. Integrity is one of the values we hold dear."

Moir writes that as a born-and-bred South African company, Woolworths "cares deeply about the long-term sustainability of our country. We've made significant contributions, through programmes like MySchool, to socio-economic development. We'll continue supporting transformation and socio-economic development because they're essential for our country's (and our company's) future."

Wall disabled

Meanwhile, in radical move, the retailer has disabled its Facebook page and posted an open letter to its customers...

"Woolies fans,
"Disabling our wall was not a decision we took lightly and not one we're particularly happy about. But when your page becomes little more than a platform for a well-orchestrated campaign of hate speech, we owe it to our customers not to subject them to such vitriol in our own house.

"We have, in a variety of channels, repeatedly refuted the claims being made against us. We have also allowed thousands of comments on our Facebook page, debating the pros and cons of Employment Equity as a national debate... deleting only overt hate speech and comments inciting violence.

"However, we've always put our customers first... and many, many customers have asked us to stop hosting this vitriol. We will re-open our page as soon as we think we can resume reasonable discussion."
 
More options
Wessel Bosman
It is okay to give preferential treatment to increase representation, it is definitely NOT Okay to exclude certain groups entirely, which is what Woolworths has done. This is discrimination and doesn't allow a fair opportunity for white job applicants in positions where no suitable candidates from other races can be found.

I will definitely still boycott Woolworths regardless of their PR efforts, they are still wrong. If Ian Mohr really wants to prove a point, he should resign and replace his own position with an employee of Suitable Race requirements, then we can see hoe sincere he is about transformation and not just participating because it is a corporate governance requirement. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 08:21
Anniemouse
I don't think you understand what is going on at all. You are so rooted in your one sided dark glasses viewpoint you cannot even allow yourself to read the truth. Woolworths is one of the only places in the world to activate some of their sustainable products ranges in store and so well. I think its fair businss practise to say the farm needs more apple trees in this orchard because we have cherry, peach, plum, pear and quamquat we really need to make sure that we are diverse enough to give a voice to all sides in every single department of our farm. So we ask just for apple trees to apply, because we need ONLY APPLE TREES right now! And isn't the north orchard in need of peach and plum trees. This is a fair farm, everyone gets the opportunity to grow within it and having a voice. This makes Woolworths the most forward thinking shopping centre in the country, really acting on our best interest, in far more than just advertising! Get off your high horse, you noodle! Posted on 7 Sep 2012 12:49
pasau
using pointless analogies only makes you look stupid. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 12:51
Nicole Ferger
Sorry, my continued support has as of recently been discontinued.

Yes there might be a quota of black employees but then employ them as they come - if they have the qualifications and suitability for that position. Don't make the position fit the person, take the person that pits the position. Give everyone an equal chance.

A former customer. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 10:26
pasau
Woolies got what it deserved. As for "well-orchestrated campaign of hate speech" it seems the company is getting PR lessons, among other things, from the anc. Frankly it doesn't deserve white rands. Hope its happy with its new market profile. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 10:35
SitDown
This just shows that we are far from being a rainbow nation. We still have the two distinct camps: Blacks vs Whites. It's so sad that we are having this debate and more sad that white people are boycotting Woolworths. Why does everything have to be so political? I support whoever appreciates my business. Woolies SERVICE and PRODUCTS are great, so I support them. Let them employ whoever they want to employ, as long as I get my money's worth in their products and service. This whole thing is ridiculous!!!!! Posted on 7 Sep 2012 13:03
Murray Campbell
Stand up Woolies and take the PR hiding like a man.

Let this be a lesson to companies who only use their online marketing strategies to communicate with their customers, it can hurt if it goes wrong. I don't think taking down the FB page was a required step, having a more transparent employment strategy may have become a winner with their new target markets. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 13:09
Sick of small minds
I agree - BEE is now a thing of the past, Lets level the playing field and appoint people qualified to do the job and provide the best possible service and not on skin colour BEE has created a huge slump in our economy.Woolies ia credible and still leader of the pack and will continue to provide the best quality of international standard to its clients. Head in the trenches, I say - like all things remotely racist - it will blow over until the next thing crops up. Please move on and get a life and see the big picture. Its not always about being black!! Posted on 7 Sep 2012 13:21
PinkPanther
Some one made a comment about putting and end to BEE so we can start being on the same level. The fact is we are not on the same level and we are not going to be on the same level for many years!!The wrongs of Apartheid will be with us for years to come. To make sure that we are all threated the same laws were put in place and that's how BEE came to be.

Until future generations are not affected by Apartheid the need for BEE will remain! Posted on 7 Sep 2012 13:52
Laurence Botha
The psychology behind Social Media seems to be lost to Woolworths... And this is not their first mistake on it. Seriously guys??? What I would like to see is this list of requests by customers for Woolworths to disable the Facebook page. Really, I am supposed to believe this. South Africans are not so stupid Woolies... Posted on 7 Sep 2012 13:22
Concerned Citizen
Woolies will and always will try to pull the Wool over our eyes as they have to follow the racist policies of BEE. Woolies are good little soldiers, Yes Sir No Sir, we at Woolworths are a well orchestrated business. We will play your tune over and over. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 13:29
Martin Hugo
I'm so sick of South Africans looking for fires where there are none. There are much more important things to worry about in our economy, and at the end of the day we always get great products and service from Woolies. I see opportunities growing for white South Africans, but as long as people hold onto their negativity they will always live in fear and never grab the opportunities in front of them. We can go look at Ads from hundreds of different companies and come to the same conclusion of "racism". I think people are just looking for something to bitch about and at present Woolies is on the receiving end. People should grow up. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 14:14
Lerato Maloka
Forget LIKE, I love the truth in this. Thank you! Posted on 7 Sep 2012 15:03
Sick of small minds
Pink Panther, I think the buck stopped with our generation. Our children are the saviour if we are teaching the right morals and ethics which in this day and age of social media and the internet, I seriously doubt. I just hope Woolies will still be around to supply my child with the best possible products and service. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 14:39
Zinhle Lukhele
Sick of small minds, I wish the buck stopped with our generation. There are thounsands of black families who will continue to be in the cycle of poverty. Thats why we cannot end BEE. A lot of other things like education need to go hand in hand with BEE also.

I do agree with you that teaching morals and ethics is key. Its more important now since children aren't just looking at their parents for influence. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 15:20
Lardie Lardie
Here's the thing, we all have choices in life, if you would like to stop shopping at woolies, go right ahead. People get way too emotional and sensitive about issues they dont fully understand. I will continue supporting woolies because its a choice i'm making. Stop making a noise for the rest of us! I hope you find the satisfaction you need wherever you will choose to shop! Posted on 7 Sep 2012 16:48
Patric Isaac
This is what i term new South Africa,we all know that previously African were margnalised to the point that they were not given a chance to prove themselves,now we are trying to close that gap,i can say white are still in woolworths and having better postions,the only problem is that they are afraid of the gap as now it seems as soon things will be equal,to me as a customer of woolies i am enjoying my experiences,to the group that are fighting against the equality i say forward we go backwards never. Posted on 7 Sep 2012 16:51
langa dube
I thought Pick & Pay would've been the retail company to receive this kind of backlash from their progressive employment equity stance and their HR policies- part of why they have been embraced in townships and other spheres of our diverse society. Think the issue here is rather more rooted in the misconception that Woolworths is a white retail stronghold and because of that, their customer base wishes to dictate that it go against legislated employment equity policy. Employment equity and BEE are necessary policies for those that lack any vision- these policies are the reason SA has not been dragged into chaos by the historically marginalised. Maybe Woolworths should follow Pick and Pay's example and start diversifying into all the different parts of our society, so that when it does advertise posts, the reason for the criteria can become more apparent. A company may suffer if it adopts a progressively HR policy while it perceived to have a near exclusive customer base- that is the case with Woolies when one looks at the store locations as a form of reference. Posted on 8 Sep 2012 06:20
Hedda G
Yeah, life is sooo tough for whites in South Africa. NOT! Posted on 10 Sep 2012 11:21
Walter Pike
The decision to disable the facebook page is not a great one. You give up your access to all that data, and the opportunity for fans to defend and like the SA Government decision to put its military bases on high alert because a youth activist addresses a small, tiny group of soldiers you give the attackers credibility a commodity of which they had very little. Posted on 14 Sep 2012 11:56
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. defamation, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.

Subscribe to industry newsletters

Bizcommunity has over 400 industry contributors and we always welcome further contributions and contributors.

Subscribe

Receive free email newsletter

Make us your homepageAdd us to your favoritesRSS feedGet biz on your phoneFollow us

Invite

Tell a friend about us