Like a scenario from an Indiana Jones movie, the treasure represented by freelance journalists, editors and writers remains doggedly elusive and untapped by public relations companies and in-house departments.
While more than 80% of all media releases that land in newsrooms still cliff-dive directly into the wasteland of "File 13", a veritable cornucopia of sustained impact, publicity, goodwill and damned fine PR lies dormant.
Despite the media explosion and kaleidoscopic panorama of communication tools available to public relations and communications execs, good ol' quality column-centimetres remain reliable yet tantalisingly elusive.
Not only do public relations courses at universities and colleges have a strong and appropriate emphasis on the writing of press releases, but the plethora of workshops, seminars and ad hoc training programmes in this seemingly arcane craft underscore its lingering importance.
Two news editors and a chief sub/managing editor told me last year that fewer than 10% of the PR releases they receive actually make it across their desks. "I bump what I think has potential to a reporter. If he or she screws it up ... well, then it's just not used," the chief sub summed it up.
And yet each will gladly publish a good feature piece "if we could get it". My own experience over 30 years in journalism and PR, and now as a teacher of these, supports her view. Writing for the media is a craft and demands talent. The principles can and should be taught, but there is a huge chasm between head-knowledge and penmanship.
The fact that so many releases are still-born stuns me. I shudder to think how many great features or powerful and compelling human-interest pieces have never seen the light of day. I have yet to meet the client company, no matter what its field of business, that doesn't have at least one damned fine feature hiding away somewhere.
You just need to know where to look. That, folks, is the Lost Treasure of Freelancia.
The secret is threefold: Know Where to look, Know What will "sell", and Tell It to Sell It.
These are fundamental skills seasoned journalists have learnt and honed over many years. In the same way as one may learn karate or tap-dancing, it takes years of experience for the moves to become second nature.
Here are some simple guidelines to identifying and working with top freelancers:
Reputation. While real estate agents and outdoor advertisers will chant "Location. Location. Location", the freelance journalist's mantra is Reputation, reputation, reputation. Credibility. A sure way to distinguish real professionals is by their track records - and the good ones will be proud to show you. Ask to see their cuttings books, especially the more recent ones.
Business expertise. Have they been to the mountain or do they just talk a good climb. Do they speak Boardroom or Bottomline. Many have worked in public affairs, promotions, advertising. Ask for referrals and check him/her out. Professionals don't mind and this will help you match the freelancer to the job.
For the really good all-round freelancers to have survived demands adaptability. Check if they are still on top of developments today.
Are they solutions-orientated? The outstanding freelancer is highly creative, original, overflowing with ideas - and questions. They see connections where others meet dead-ends, and the response: "Okay. But what if ..." is as common as their refusal to take "No." for an answer.
Freelance writers, photojournalists and editors are hungry, highly professional, versatile, keen to forge lasting relationships, creative, competitive and damned good at their craft - otherwise they don't survive.
With the vast benefits to be gained through using reputable and seasoned freelancers, the fact that the public relations industry, which prides itself on creativity in most other spheres, seems mired in the old mindset of carpet-bombing newspapers, magazines, radio, TV and the internet with tons of trashcan fodder doesn't make sound sense.
Llewellyn Kriel lectures in Journalism and Public Relations at Varsity College in Durban. He has won numerous awards for journalism and public speaking. He is widely published locally and internationally.
Xolani Zungu (Nelspruit)
Well said!-
The author is modest. While working some years ago with the Johannesburg CCTV project, Llewellyn Kriel managed to secure a big coup for the City of Johannesburg by getting a double-page spread in TIME magazine! I do not know many freelancer journalist who have done that! Posted on 23 Feb 2006 06:30
It is clear that you as a specialist desperately needs the assistance of a freelance editor...
I am in PR and I have also received comments from many journalists about the appalling quality of press releases that come from many PR agencies. Fortunately, it is usually when they are calling to say, "thanks great press release - you should see some of the rubbish I get!" Posted on 24 Feb 2006 08:35
Luister boetie, the whole "90% of press releases go to file 13" is an international phenomenon, and not just a South African problem.
Freelancers are not the solution, as any good PR company will have employed people who can a) write b) advise their clients when they HAVE a story and when they HAVE NOT c) build a strong relationship between their client and the media
In any event, I guarantee that it would take a freelancer triple the time to capture the story in the relevant 'in-house style' and understand the technicalities of the story. Time is money, china.
IF you have to outsource your writing work, then you're not a PR practitioners arse. Feenish en klaar, swaar. Posted on 27 Feb 2006 12:37
Koos, if you don't outsource your writing, then you're just another of those mindless PR agencies sending out reams of garbage just because the campaign (that you cut and pasted from the previous client in any case) said you had to write four press releases that month. Chances are you can't write, and your media relations probably stinks as well. Wake up and smell the coffee. Boet. Posted on 4 Mar 2006 18:31
You are the doos, my china, because you assume that all PR agencies are made up of talentless bimbos who are only good for cocktail party smooching. If you had any real grasp of the industry, and its clear you don't, you would know that there are a number of good PR agencies out there who have excellent writers on their books. A PR practitioner who can't write is like a an airline pilot being afraid of flying. Posted on 6 Mar 2006 16:04
Right now, managing a copy taster's desk in Joeys, I have just filed 63 so-called "media releases" in the bin. The most worthless turgid dungheap of trash I have seen in a long, loooong while!
Temporarily manning (sexist, heh?) this desk, I now have first-hand experience of what my fulltime media friends have been exposed to all these years ... and I understand why they have such a low opinion of PR folk!
PLEASE give us a list of the "reputable" PR companies who employ good writers, so I don't have to actually read this rubbish before trashing it. Posted on 17 Mar 2006 17:08
If only those freelancers would advertise themselves somewhere I have been looking for a freelancer for months!!! Find me just one! Posted on 8 Mar 2006 11:11
... here I am, shamelessly promoting myself as a freelancer! Leeanne, my mail address is above. I look forward to talking to you. Posted on 8 Mar 2006 13:27
given his aggressive response to my initial post, he's probably a freelancer of some sort himself, or maybe he has mates in the field. Judging from his posts, he doesn't seem to have an awful lot of writing talent, certainly no more than I have and I'm a middle-aged Afrikaner, but hey.... Posted on 8 Mar 2006 12:53
Koos, I'm sorry you saw my response to your post as aggressive - it was meant to read totally differently! But thanks for the punt, however back-handed ... Posted on 8 Mar 2006 13:19
komaan seun, you called me a 'doos,' there's no other way of reading this 'differently.' Have you considered Anger Management classes? Fishing at the vaal with a litre bottle of klippies will also help Posted on 9 Mar 2006 11:39
Come on, Koos, you've been called worse in your time and emerged unscathed. I was just doing some good, old-fashioned s***-stirring! And I'm not much of a Klippies man, though I'd be happy to share a KVW 10-year-old on ice with you! Posted on 10 Mar 2006 09:49
mr kriel was my coach when he worked at the daily news. one heck of a guy! sincere, dedicated, an excellent writer and bloody genuine person. u dont find many people like him and yeah if he did rat then it was probably cos the skunks were not doin their jobs. south africa is just filled with lazy people given jobs becos of this, that or the other ... so well done! rat again and again until this bloody country gets people who actually work! and stop gossiping, worrying bot their hair and makeup and chatting online to their friends on facebook, blah blah blah Posted on 27 Feb 2008 09:48
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This Message Board accepts no liability of legal consequences that arise from the Message Boards (e.g. libel, slander, or other such crimes). All posted messages are the sole property of their respective authors. The maintainer does retain the right to remove any message posts for whatever reasons. People that post messages to this forum are not to libel/slander nor in any other way depict a company, entity, individual(s), or service in a false light; should they do so, the legal consequences are theirs alone. Bizcommunity.com will disclose authors' IP addresses to authorities if compelled to do so by a court of law.